Threaded cortical bone dowels in lumbosacral arthrodesis: a review

Lumbar fusion is a common spinal surgery, for which numerous devices have been developed to aid in segment stabilization. A threaded cortical bone dowel is a machined and processed bone allograft which is one such development. Threaded cortical bone dowels are attractive because of their osteoconductive nature and the opportunity to load them with osteogenic morselized bone autograft or osteoinductive growth factors, such as bone morphogenetic proteins. Although threaded cortical bone dowels have been in clinical use for more than 5 years, they have not been the subject of a comprehensive review. The current article covers the history, preparation, uses, safety, and efficacy of threaded cortical bone dowels in lumbosacral interbody fusion.     

Intervertebral fixation: clinical results with anterior cages

Anterior lumbar interbody fusion has several clinical advantages over posterior or posterolateral lumbar fusion. Interbody fusion procedures place bone grafts within the disc space at the center of rotation of the vertebral motion segment. The intervertebral area is highly vascular, and the grafts have a wide contact area in the weight-bearing axis of the spinal motion segment. The high rates of fusion associated with the use of the threaded intervertebral fusion cages may be attributed, in part, to the following: (1) removal of the cartilagenous end plates and exposure of bleeding cancellous bony surfaces, (2) reestablishment of anatomic intradiscal height and tensioning of the annulus and ligamentous structures around the disc space, (3) use of appropriately sized implants to engage the peripheral apophysis of the vertebral end plates, and (4) use of autogenous grafts. Threaded interbody constructs provide adequate strength to ensure that no plastic deformation occurs within the maximum physiologic range. Dynamic testing of these implants also has shown that these implants are able to resist cyclic fatigue within typical normal daily physiologic loading. Stability testing has shown that when inserted anteriorly, these devices reduce intervertebral motion and increase spinal stiffness.     

Use of osteopromotive growth factors, demineralized bone matrix, and ceramics to enhance spinal fusion

Recently developed materials that can enhance fusion rates for posterolateral lumbar arthrodesis may be used alone or in combination with autogenous bone grafts. Novel osteopromotive growth factor preparations are currently under scrutiny; these include autogenous growth factor concentrate, bovine bone-derived osteoinductive protein, and recombinant human MP52. Demineralized bone matrix products may enhance or extend grafts. However, few studies, especially prospective randomized clinical trials, have assessed their efficacy, so it is difficult to compare formulations. Ceramics have been evaluated in animal studies and human clinical trials for a variety of applications in spinal surgery. These materials function best as bone graft extenders or as bioactive osteoinductive material carriers in posterolateral lumbar fusions. They have the advantage of variable porosity, low cost, and ease of manufacture. Hydroxyapatite/tricalcium phosphate ceramics have been shown to perform as well as autogenous bone grafts but with fewer complications.     

Advances in Spinal Interbody Cages

Since the late 1980s, spinal interbody cages (ICs) have been used to aid bone fusion in a variety of spinal disorders. Utilized to restore intervertebral height, enable bone graft containment for arthrodesis, and restore anterior column biomechanical stability, ICs have since evolved to become a highly successful means of achieving fusion, being associated with less postoperative pain, shorter hospital stay, fewer complications and higher rates of fusion when than bone graft only spinal fusion. IC design and materials have changed considerably over the past two decades. The threaded titanium‐alloy cylindrical screw cages, typically filled with autologous bone graft, of the mid‐1990s achieved greater fusion rates than bone grafts and non‐threaded cages. Threaded screw cages, however, were soon found to be less stable in extension and flexion; additionally, they had a high incidence of cage subsidence. As of the early 2000s, non‐threaded box‐shaped titanium or polyether ether ketone IC designs have become increasingly more common. This modern design continues to achieve greater cage stability in flexion, axial rotation and bending. However, cage stability and subsidence, bone fusion rates and surgical complications still require optimization. Thus, this review provides an update of recent research findings relevant to ICs over the past 3 years, highlighting trends in optimization of cage design, materials, alternatives to bone grafts, and coatings that may enhance fusion.     

椎管减压植骨内固定治疗腰椎管狭窄并腰椎不稳症

目的 探讨椎管减压植骨内固定治疗腰椎管狭窄并腰椎不稳症的疗效。方法采用保留棘突韧带复合结构的全椎板切除减压、国产通用型脊柱内固定系统固定、椎体间植骨融合加入路侧横突间植骨融合术治疗腰椎管狭窄并腰椎不稳症103例。结果经临床、MRI、X线片检查诊断单节段腰椎管狭窄15例,双节段狭窄53例,三节段29例,四节段6例。术后随访86例,随访时间平均3年3个月,优良率89．5％。结论采用椎管减压、椎弓根系统内固定、植骨融合。可有效维持和重建脊柱的稳定,解除患者症状,是目前治疗腰椎管狭窄并腰椎不稳症的较好治疗方法。     

Accelerating lumbar fusions by combining rhBMP-2 with allograft bone: a prospective analysis of interbody fusion rates and clinical outcomes.

BACKGROUND CONTEXT: Recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2) is an osteoinductive protein approved for use in the anterior lumbar interspace. High fusion rates with rhBMP-2 have been reported with threaded interbody allograft dowels. There may be a clinical benefit for the patient by adding rhBMP-2 to the allograft. PURPOSE: To compare the fusion rates and clinical outcomes of patients treated with allograft interbody fusions with and without the addition of rhBMP-2. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective consecutive patient enrollment with minimum 24-month follow-up. PATIENT SAMPLE: Seventy-five patients with lumbar interbody fusions at 1-3 spinal segments. OUTCOMES MEASURES: Clinical: Numerical Rating Scale (NRS) and Oswestry Disability Index (ODI). Radiographic: X-ray and computed tomographic scan analysis using the Molinari-Bridwell fusion scale. METHODS: Seventy-five patients scheduled for lumbar fusion were enrolled sequentially. Group 1: 30 patients had anterior interbody allografts alone. Group 2: 45 patients had anterior interbody allograft filled with rhBMP-2. All cases had posterior pedicle screw instrumentation. A total of 165 surgical levels (62 allograft alone/103 allograft+BMP) were included. Fusion data and clinical outcomes were collected for a minimum of 2 years after surgery. RESULTS: Statistically higher fusion rates were observed in the patients with BMP at all time points compared with allograft alone. Group 2 (+ BMP) fusion rates were 94%, 100%, and 100% at 6, 12, and 24 months after surgery. Group 1 (-BMP) fusion rates were 66%, 84%, and 89% at the same time intervals. Clinical outcomes were significantly improved in Group 2 compared with Group 1 at 6 months. There were no revisions (0%) in the BMP group and 4 revision fusion surgeries (13%) in the allograft group. No untoward effects were attributable to the rhBMP-2. CONCLUSIONS: Our study confirms the efficacy of an innovative lumbar fusion technique: an interbody femoral ring allograft, combined with an osteoinductive stimulant (rhBMP-2), protected by pedicle screws. This combination of a structural interbody allograft with rhBMP-2 eliminates the insult of iliac crest harvest, allows for reliable radiographic analysis, and results in successful fusion formation in 100% of the cases in this study.     

The efficacy of autologous laminectomy bone combined with bone graft extenders in posterolateral lumbar instrumented fusion

Iliac crest autograft has been used successfully for many years in spinal fusion operations. The main advantages to iliac crest autograft are the easy accessibility, the robust combination of osteogenic, osteoinductive, and osteoconductive properties, and the resultant efficacy. However, autograft iliac crest bone graft has fallen out of favor in spinal fusion operations due to the morbidity associated with harvest. Various bone graft substitutes have become commercially available that provide similar fusion rates when compared to iliac crest autograft. None of the bone graft substitutes can match iliac crest bone graft in all 3 osteogenic, osteoinductive, and osteoconductive parameters, but when combined with local autologous laminectomy bone and, therefore, used as a bone graft extender, may very well come close. This article reviews the main categories of bone graft substitutes and extenders and the role of these substances when combined with local autologous laminectomy bone in posterolateral lumbar instrumented fusion operations.     

Revision strategies for salvaging or improving failed cylindrical cages.

STUDY DESIGN: This is a review of 20 patients who experienced failure of threaded interbody fusion cages and underwent surgical correction. OBJECTIVE: To review the causes and possible treatment strategies for failed cylindrical cages. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Intraoperative complications have been described in the past; however, management of the postoperative patient with failure of interbody fusion devices has not been described. METHODS: In 20 patients with failed threaded titanium fusion cages (18 Bagby and Kuslich Devices [BAK; Sulzer-Spine Tech, Minneapolis, MN], 2 Ray Threaded Fusion Cages [Ray TFC; Surgical Dynamics, Norwalk, CT) who underwent revision surgery, all had failure before successful arthrodesis was achieved. Eight of the original titanium cages had been inserted anteriorly (7 laparoscopically), and 12 had been inserted for posterior interbody lumbar fusion. Before the revision surgery, five of the implants were thought to be solid by the referring surgeon, but pseudarthrosis was clearly present in all. In addition, 14 other explanted BAK devices were subjected to undecalcified histologic preparation, quantitative histomorphometry, and histopathologic analysis. RESULTS: The average length of time before revision surgery (implant duration) was 31.8 weeks (range, 1-156 weeks). The most common revision procedure was posterior exploration of the symptomatic nerve root with foraminotomy for unrecognized lateral recess stenosis (11 cases) or excision of iatrogenically herniated intervertebral disc fragments (4 cases). However, four cages inserted through posterior exposure during an interbody lumbar fusion procedure had to be removed because of migration into the spinal canal. In nine cases posterior pedicle screw instrumentation was necessary in addition to posterolateral fusion using iliac crest bone grafting. CONCLUSIONS: All 20 cages failed because of surgical technique rather than an intrinsic defect in fusion cage technology. The factors associated with failure of the original insertion procedure were failure to achieve adequate distraction of the anulus fibrosis; undersized cages, especially when placed through the posterior interbody lumbar fusion approach; cerebrospinal fluid leakage or pseudomeningocele; Type 2 diabetes mellitus; the use of local bone graft rather than iliac crest inside the cage; anterior insertion in an excessively lateral position resulting in symptoms of a far lateral disc herniation; and failure to identify the spinal midline during an anterior approach.     

Platelet-rich plasma combined with hydroxyapatite for lumbar interbody fusion promoted bone formation and decreased an inflammatory pain neuropeptide in rats

STUDY DESIGN.: A prospective interventional trial, using a rat model of lumbar interbody fusion. OBJECTIVE.: To examine the potential efficacy of platelet-rich plasma (PRP) for lumbar interbody fusion, using hydroxyapatite (HA). SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA.: PRP is an autologous product containing a high concentration of platelets in a small volume of plasma and has osteoinductive effects. HA has osteoconductive ability and has been used in combination with autogenous bone for spine fusion. However, reports using PRP with HA for spine fusion are very few. The purpose of this study was to examine the efficacy of PRP with HA for spinal interbody fusion and at the same time to estimate the change in immunoreactivity of the inflammatory neuropeptide, calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP), in dorsal root ganglion (DRG) neurons innervating spinal discs. METHODS.: A total of 35 Sprague-Dawley rats were used in this study. Twenty-one rats were used for conducting interbody fusion experiments, 7 rats were used as immunostaining controls, and 7 other rats were used as blood donors for making PRP. L5-L6 interbody fusion was performed on 21 rats using HA + PRP (n = 7), HA + platelet-poor plasma (n = 7), or HA + saline (n = 7). Simultaneously, Fluoro-Gold neurotracer was applied to the intervertebral space to detect DRG neurons innervating the discs. L5-L6 lumbar radiographs were obtained and lumbar DRGs were immunostained for CGRP. The rate of bone union and the change in CGRP immunoreactive DRG neurons innervating the discs were evaluated and compared among groups. RESULTS.: All L5-L6 lumbar discs were fused in the PRP + HA group (fused 7/total 7), whereas only 1 case was fused in the platelet-poor plasma group (1 of 7) and no cases in the HA-only group (0 of 7), which was a significant difference. Upon immunohistochemical analysis, CGRP-positive neurons innervated L5-L6 intervertebral discs in nonunion cases, and these were significantly increased compared with those in union cases. CONCLUSION.: Our study suggests that using PRP with HA was beneficial for spine fusion. This combination may promote bone union and also decrease inflammatory neuropeptide in sensory neurons innervating the discs.     

Successful Spinal Fusion by E. coli-derived BMP-2-adsorbed Porous β-TCP Granules: A Pilot Study

Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) were originally identified as osteoinductive proteins. With cloning of BMP genes, studies of BMPs and their clinical application have advanced. However, with increasing clinical applications, drug delivery systems and production costs have become more important issues. To address these issues, we asked whether E. coli-derived rhBMP-2 (E-BMP-2)-adsorbed porous β-TCP granules could achieve posterolateral lumbar fusion in a rabbit model similar to autogenous bone grafts. Lumbar spinal fusion masses were evaluated by 3-D computed tomography, mechanical testing, and histological analyses 8 weeks after surgery. By these measures E-BMP-2-adsorbed β-TCP granules achieved lumbar spinal fusion in dose-dependent fashion in a rabbit model as well as autogenous bone graft. Our preliminary findings suggest E-BMP-2-adsorbed porous β-TCP could be a novel, effective alternative to autogenous bone grafting for generating new bone and promoting regenerative repair of bone, and potentially utilizable in the clinical setting for treating spinal disorders.     

Electrical stimulation of spinal fusion: a scientific and clinical update.

BACKGROUND CONTEXT: For over two decades, a number of electrical stimulation devices have achieved increasing acceptance as adjuncts to lumbar spinal fusion. Direct current electrical stimulation, pulsed electromagnetic fields and more recently capacitive coupling have been shown to have varying effectiveness when used to increase the success of lumbar spinal fusion. PURPOSE: The various electrical stimulation devices will be reviewed with respect to the available basic science evidence validating their use as spinal fusion adjuncts, as well as a review of the current clinical data available to allow not only a discussion of their overall clinical applicability, but more specifically their use in specific spinal disorders and spinal fusion techniques. METHODS: The existing peer-reviewed scientific literature will be used to ascertain the scientific and clinical efficacy of electrical stimulation to enhance lumbar spinal fusion. CONCLUSION: Electrical stimulation devices have emerged as valid adjuncts to attaining a solid lumbar spinal fusion. However, not all stimulators are equally scientifically effective nor are they equally effective clinically in achieving increased fusion success.     

颈椎前路环锯法减压术后三种处理方法的生物力学评价

目的 研究环锯法减压后不植骨、自体柱状髂骨植骨及螺柱状颈椎内固定器植入后,三者的生物力学稳定性,为临床手术提供依据。方法 采用新鲜青年尸体标本,分别用三种方法处理C5－6段,测量其在1．53nm的纯力矩载荷条件下的稳定性并用相邻椎体间的空间位移和卡当角表示。结果 环锯法减术后,手术节段的稳定性明显减轻。自体髂骨植入后,椎间隙高度升高,伸屈活动度下降,但其稳定性仍比正常时差。螺柱状颈椎内固定器植入,前屈、侧屈和旋转的活动度明显较正常时小,但后伸范围无明显改变。结论 环锯减压后如不植骨有可能不融合或畸形愈合。椎间植骨能明显改善减压节段的稳定性,但手术后仍应采用辅助外固定。螺柱状颈椎内固定器不但能维持椎间隙高度,防止术后畸形,而且有足够的稳定性,术后不必应用外固定。     

Posterior lumbar interbody fusion (PLIF) with cages and local bone graft in the treatment of spinal stenosis

Posterior lumbar interbody fusion (PLIF) implants are increasingly being used for 360 degrees fusion after decompression of lumbar spinal stenosis combined with degenerative instability. Both titanium and PEEK (PolyEtherEtherKetone) implants are commonly used. Assessing the clinical and radiological results as well as typical complications, such as migration of the cages, is important. In addition, questions such as which radiological parameters can be used to assess successful fusion, and whether the exclusive use of local bone graft is sufficient, are frequently debated. We prospectively evaluated 30 patients after PLIF instrumentation for degenerative lumbar spinal canal stenosis, over a course of 42 months. In all cases, titanium cages and local bone graft were used for spondylodesis. The follow-up protocol of these 30 cases included standardised clinical and radiological evaluation at 3, 6, 12 and 42 months after surgery. Overall satisfactory results were achieved. With one exception, a stable result was achieved with restoration of the intervertebral space in the anterior column. After 42 months of follow-up in most cases, a radiologically visible loss of disc space height can be demonstrated. Clinically relevant migration of the cage in the dorsal direction was detected in one case. Based on our experience, posterior lumbar interbody fusion (PLIF) can be recommended for the treatment of monosegmental and bisegmental spinal stenosis, with or without segmental instability. Postoperative evaluation is mainly based on clinical parameters since the titanium implant affects the diagnostic value of imaging studies and is responsible for artefacts. The results observed in our group of patients suggest that local autologous bone graft procured from the posterior elements after decompression is an adequate material for bone grafting in this procedure.     

Lumbar sagittal contour after posterior interbody fusion: threaded devices alone versus vertical cages plus posterior instrumentation

STUDY DESIGN: An observational radiographic study examining lumbar sagittal contour of patients undergoing posterior interbody arthrodesis. OBJECTIVES: To compare operative alterations of lumbar sagittal contour after posterior interbody fusion using threaded interbody devices alone versus vertical cages combined with posterior compression instrumentation. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Technique-related alterations of lumbar sagittal contour during interbody arthrodesis have received little attention in the spinal literature. METHODS: Standing lumbar radiographs were measured for preoperative and postoperative segmental lordosis at levels undergoing posterior interbody arthrodesis using either stand-alone side-by-side threaded devices or vertical cages combined with posterior transpedicular compression instrumentation. Sagittal plane segmental correction (or loss of correction) was calculated and statistically compared. RESULTS: The radiographs of 30 patients (34 spinal segments) undergoing lumbar or lumbosacral arthrodesis were compared. Seventeen patients (18 segments) had undergone interbody fusion using threaded cages,whereas 13 patients (16 segments) underwent fusion using vertically oriented mesh cages combined with posterior compression instrumentation. Preoperative segmental lordosis averaged 8 degrees for both groups. For patients undergoing fusion with threaded cages, there was a mean lordotic loss of 3 degrees/segment. For patients undergoing fusion with vertically oriented mesh cages combined with posterior compression instrumentation,there was a mean lordotic gain of 5 degrees/segment. This difference in segmental sagittal plane contour was highly significant (P = 0.00). CONCLUSION: Threaded fusion devices placed under interbody distraction with the endplates parallel fail to preserve or reestablish segmental lordosis. Vertical cages, however, when combined with posterior compression instrumentation, not only maintain segmental lordosis, but also can correct sagittal plane deformity.     

椎间植骨融合加SRS 系统治疗腰椎滑脱症

目的 探讨运用Spondylolisthesis Reduction System(SRS)提拉复位系统加环锯取髂骨于椎体间行单侧或双侧植骨融合治疗峡部不连性腰椎滑脱症。方法 临床共治疗43例腰椎峡部不连性滑脱病人，按手术复位，症状改善，骨性融合，内固定材料牢固情况进行疗效评价。结果 43例患者获得1～5年(平均3年2个月)随访，按我们自拟疗效标准，优33例，良7例，可3例，无症状加重病例。完全复位38例。无内固定松动断裂发生。结论 环锯椎间植骨融合加SRS系统，能达到很好的复位及牢固的固定，从而达到椎间的骨性融合。手术操作简便，效果满意，如能采取双侧椎间同时植骨，增加融合面积，效果更佳。     

Bone dowels in anterior lumbar interbody fusion

Since the Food and Drug Administration approved the Babgy-Kuslich BAK cage for anterior lumbar interbody fusion (ALIF), various threaded interbody fusion devices have been introduced. Bone dowels offer several theoretical advantages over cages with regard to stress shielding; the purpose of this study was to assess the efficacy of bone dowels in interbody fusion. All patients undergoing ALIF performed by the senior author between 1998 and 2001 were retrospectively reviewed. Patients' preoperative and postoperative neurologic status, functional status, and both back and radicular pain were assessed according to a previously published outcome measure. Between 1998 and 2000, 23 patients underwent ALIF with cortical femoral allograft bone dowels. One patient underwent simultaneous bone dowel and titanium cage placements and was therefore excluded from further analysis. The 22 remaining patients underwent a total of 33 fused segments; of these, 21 patients were available for follow-up. Mean clinical follow-up was 30.6 months. Mean imaging follow-up was 21 months. There were 5 instances of radiographic nonunion (3 symptomatic and 2 asymptomatic). The incidence of technical failures and complications related to the bone dowels was 17%. Bone dowels failed and caused symptoms only in patients with a stand-alone ALIF. There were no clinical failures in patients treated with supplemental anterior or posterior spinal fixation. These data demonstrate that marginal fusion rates and functional success rates can be achieved using stand-alone bone dowels for ALIF. The clinical success and fusion rates are significantly higher if ALIF dowels are shielded from stress with rigid spinal instrumentation.     

The failure of ethylene oxide gas-sterilized freeze-dried bone graft for thoracic and lumbar spinal fusion

Thirty-seven patients underwent posterior and/or posterolateral spinal fusion using ethylene oxide gas-sterilized freeze-dried bank bone graft. Thirteen patients had discogenic back pain, eight with prior failed laminectomy procedures, and five undergoing initial spinal surgery. Six patients had isthmic spondylolisthesis, three with associated radicular complaints, and two patients had degenerative spondylolisthesis. Seven patients with spinal fractures and nine patients with scoliosis underwent spinal fusion with associated instrumentation. Pseudarthroses were detected in 28 patients (76%), and 18 patients (49%) underwent pseudarthrosis repair procedures using autogenous iliac bone graft. At surgery, the prior gas-sterilized freeze-dried bone graft was noted to have been almost completely resorbed. Ethylene oxide sterilization has been found experimentally in animal models to damage the osteoinductive ability of bone grafts. Ethylene oxide gas-sterilized freeze-dried bank bone graft is inferior to autogenous bone graft or bank bone graft preserved and/or sterilized by other methods. Its use in thoracic or lumbar posterior or posterolateral fusion cannot be recommended.     

The role of human bone morphogenetic proteins in spinal fusion

The attainment of a stable arthrodesis is critical to the successful management of some types of spinal disorders. Autologous iliac-crest bone graft has been the most commonly utilized substance associated with predictable healing in spinal fusion applications. Although alternative graft substances exist, these have not been shown to be as uniformly effective in achieving spinal fusion. Because of the morbidity associated with bone autograft harvest, there is increasing interest in alternative graft substances and especially in the osteoinductive abilities of bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs). Several animal models have demonstrated that BMP-containing allograft or synthetic carrier medium is as effective as or superior to autograft bone in promoting spinal fusion. Furthermore, the limited number of human trials utilizing BMPs to treat nonunions in the appendicular skeleton indicate that the results found in animal models will be reproducible in the clinical setting.     

腰椎后路全椎板减压椎体间融合术治疗腰椎管狭窄临床疗效观察

目的探讨腰椎后路全椎板减压椎体间融合治疗腰椎管狭窄的疗效。方法对16例腰椎管狭窄或合并椎间盘突出的患者采用腰椎后路全椎板减压椎体间融合术治疗,对其临床资料进行回顾性分析,用Eule评定方法对其疗效进行评估。结果 16例患者全部得到随访,随访时间4个月~3年,优良率87.5%。结论腰椎后路全椎板减压椎体间融合治疗腰椎管狭窄的疗效满意,同时应严格掌握适应症,提高治疗效果。