Accounting for failure: risk-based regulation and the problems of ensuring healthcare quality in the NHS

In this paper, we examine why risk-based policy instruments have failed to improve the proportionality, effectiveness, and legitimacy of healthcare quality regulation in the National Health Service (NHS) in England. Rather than trying to prevent all possible harms, risk-based approaches promise to rationalise and manage the inevitable limits of what regulation can hope to achieve by focusing regulatory standard-setting and enforcement activity on the highest priority risks, as determined through formal assessments of their probability and consequences. As such, risk-based approaches have been enthusiastically adopted by healthcare quality regulators over the last decade. However, by drawing on historical policy analysis and in-depth interviews with 15 high-level UK informants in 2013–2015, we identify a series of practical problems in using risk-based policy instruments for defining, assessing, and ensuring compliance with healthcare quality standards. Based on our analysis, we go on to consider why, despite a succession of failures, healthcare regulators remain committed to developing and using risk-based approaches. We conclude by identifying several preconditions for successful risk-based regulation: goals must be clear and trade-offs between them amenable to agreement; regulators must be able to reliably assess the probability and consequences of adverse outcomes; regulators must have a range of enforcement tools that can be deployed in proportion to risk; and there must be political tolerance for adverse outcomes.     

In vitro generation of cytotoxic effectors activated by interleukin 2 (IL-2): comparison of autologous peripheral blood stem cells (PBSC) from adults and children

Previous studies demonstrated that ex vivo IL-2- activated PBSC could generate cytotoxic effectors without impairing haematopoietic reconstitution. Clinical experience and previous studies indicated that children with solid tumours could benefit from high-dose chemotherapy with immune modulation. We studied the generation of cytotoxic effectors from growth-factor +/- chemotherapy-mobilised PBSC from 10 patients (five adults and five children) with different solid tumours. Cells were placed in culture in serum-free culture medium supplemented with IL-2 1000 U/ml +/- IL-12 for 1, 2, 4 or 7 days. Anti-tumour cytotoxicity was tested against K562, Daudi and two neuroblastoma cell lines (Gau, NB91). Cultured adult PBSC in the presence of IL-2 (1000 U/ml) showed marked cytotoxicity against all the cell lines tested from day 1. At day 2, with an E:T ratio of 25:1, cytotoxicity was 53% +/- 10.4, 63.2% +/- 23.8, 38% +/- 9.1, and 39% +/- 15.7 against K562, Daudi, Gau and NB91, respectively. Cytotoxic activity of child PBSC was significantly lower (P < 0.05) and was displayed after longer culture times (day 4). No difference was found in the phenotype analysis of lymphoid subsets before and after IL-2 activation between adult and child PBSC. Haematological properties of the graft were not significantly impaired by IL-2 activation.     

Extensive suppuration and being overweight are factors associated with the failure of laser treatment for pilonidal disease: lessons from the first French retrospective cohort

Techniques in Coloproctology - The aim of our study was to assess the efficacy of sinus laser therapy (SiLaT) for the treatment of pilonidal disease. All adult patients treated with SiLaT in our...     

Aortic stiffness as a tissue biomarker for predicting future cardiovascular events in asymptomatic hypertensive subjects

Classical risk scores may underestimate the risk of cardiovascular events in specific risk groups suitable for early prevention, such as asymptomatic hypertensive subjects. Arterial stiffness and wave reflection are now well accepted as the most important determinants of increasing systolic and pulse pressures in aging societies, thus affording a major contribution to stroke and myocardial infarction. A major reason for measuring arterial stiffness in hypertensive patients comes from the demonstration that arterial stiffness has a predictive value for cardiovascular events, beyond classical cardiovascular risk factors. Aortic stiffening also gives direct evidence of target organ damage, and improves the determination of the overall cardiovascular risk of asymptomatic hypertensive subjects. In clinical practice, the measurement of aortic stiffness may avoid patients being mistakenly classified as at low or moderate risk, when they actually have an abnormally high aortic stiffness placing them within a higher-risk group. The present mini-review successively addresses the concept of 'tissue' biomarker, applies it to arterial stiffness, describes the methodology of measurement, gives some pathophysiological links in order to explain the occurrence of stroke and myocardial infarction in patients with high arterial stiffness, and raises the issue of whether arterial stiffness is a surrogate marker.     

Continuous Preperitoneal Infusion of Ropivacaine Provides Effective Analgesia and Accelerates Recovery after Colorectal Surgery: A Randomized, Double-blind, Placebo-controlled Study

Background: Blockade of parietal nociceptive afferents by the use of continuous wound infiltration with local anesthetics may be beneficial in a multimodal approach to postoperative pain management after major surgery. The role of continuous preperitoneal infusion of ropivacaine for pain relief and postoperative recovery after open colorectal resections was evaluated in a randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled trial.

Methods: After obtaining written informed consents, a multiholed wound catheter was placed by the surgeon in the preperitoneal space at the end of surgery in patients scheduled to undergo elective open colorectal resection by midline incision. They were thereafter randomly assigned to receive through the catheter either 0.2% ropivacaine (10-ml bolus followed by an infusion of 10 ml/h during 48 h) or the same protocol with 0.9% NaCl. In addition, all patients received patient-controlled intravenous morphine analgesia.

Results: Twenty-one patients were evaluated in each group. Compared with preperitoneal saline, ropivacaine infusion reduced morphine consumption during the first 72 h and improved pain relief at rest during 12 h and while coughing during 48 h. Sleep quality was also better during the first two postoperative nights. Time to recovery of bowel function (74 +/- 19 vs. 105 +/- 54 h; P = 0.02) and duration of hospital stay (115 +/- 25 vs. 147 +/- 53 h; P = 0.02) were significantly reduced in the ropivacaine group. Ropivacaine plasma concentrations remained below the level of toxicity. No side effects were observed.     

Ultrasound control of local anaesthetic location after TAP block performed using landmark-based technique: a cohort study

Objective

TAP is a regional anaesthetic technique where local anaesthesic (LA) is injected between the internal oblique and the transversus abdominis muscles in order to block intercostal nerves. The technique originally described, is based on the identification of the lumbar triangle of Petit as the area where to insert the needle before the LA injection. We performed a study to determine, using ultrasonography, the actual location of the LA when TAP block was performed using landmark-based technique.

Study design

Prospective and observational study.

Methods

Fifty-two patients scheduled for ileostomy closure surgery under general anaesthesia received a TAP block (20 mL 0.75% ropivacaine) based on standard anatomical landmarks technique. Ultrasonography was used immediately after the block to determine the LA placement. Failed blocks were considered when the patient required intravenous morphine in the immediate postoperative period for pain localised at the operative site.

Results

LA solution was injected in the right place in 14 cases out of 52. Only one of these patient received morphine in the postoperative period. In the remaining 38 blocks, the LA was administered in adjacent anatomical structures and 25 failed. Two injections in the peritoneum were observed.

Conclusion

The localization of LA after the TAP block being performed by landmark-based techniques is highly variable. In the majority of patients, the LA was injected in adjacent anatomical structures with unpredictable block results. This may promote the use of ultrasound-guided technique to perform the TAP block.