Pleural plaque profiles on the chest radiographs and CT scans of asbestos-exposed Japanese construction workers

Pleural plaques are asymptomatic focal thickenings of the pleura and considered the hallmark of asbestos exposure. However, it is often difficult to detect pleural plaques on chest x-rays (CXR). In a retrospective study, using chest CT scans of 140 Japanese asbestos-exposed construction workers who have probable or definite findings of pleural plaque on CXR; firstly, we proposed plaque morphology-based classification for CXR findings, and then we examined if those classified findings could be confirmed as pleural plaques on CT scans. Our morphology-based classification of pleural plaque findings included nine types. The percentages of confirmed pleural plaques on CT scans by type (number of confirmed pleural plaque on CT/number of observed on CXR) were 93% (40/43) for straight, 89% (56/63) for diamond, 88% (7/8) for double, 83% (19/23) for tapered medially, 80% (20/25) for parallel, 77% (23/30) for crescent, 79% (11/14) for tenting, 72% (18/25) for tapered-laterally (long type), and 0% (0/9) for tapered-laterally (short type). When added to the ILO classification, morphology-based classification of CXR pleural plaque findings makes its detection easier and hence chest radiograph continues to be a suitable tool for screening asbestos-related pleural plaques based on its simplicity, low radiation exposure, wide availability and cost-effectiveness.     

A patient with asbestos-induced lung cancer complicated by silicosis

A 76-year-old male died of lung cancer. At first, he was diagnosed as a silicosis, because he had worked for 30 years as a caster in shipyard and large opacities detected by chest x-ray and CT scanning. After the operation of lung cancer, numerous asbestos bodies were observed in the operated lung tissues. The detailed occupational inquiry revealed his asbestos use as a caster in shipyard. Early stage of asbestosis was suspected by chest CT scanning, but not definitely diagnosed in premortal examinations. Asbestosis, pleural plaques, silicosis and large cell carcinoma of the lung were histopathologically confirmed at the autopsy. A patient with asbestos-induced lung cancer complicated by silicosis was rarely published in the literature.     

Abnormal pulmonary function associated with diaphragmatic pleural plaques due to exposure to asbestos.

Pulmonary function was measured in 79 men with diaphragmatic pleural plaques (DPP) as the only abnormality characteristic of asbestos disease on chest radiographs. They were selected from 4572 construction and shipyard workers exposed to asbestos. Abnormalities of pulmonary function in 21 non-smokers and 43 current smokers were compared with referent values adjusted for height, age, and duration of cigarette smoking. In the non-smokers, flows (FEV1) FEF75-85 and FEV1/FVC) were reduced and TGV and RV/TGV were raised. Current smokers had similar significant reductions. Thus by contrast with some current opinion that plaques are "an index only of past asbestos exposure," workers with plaques, even limited to the diaphragm, have functional impairment typical of pulmonary asbestosis. This suggests that they have pulmonary asbestosis, which is below the threshold of radiographic recognition.     

Asbestos-induced visceral pleural fibrosis reduces pulmonary compliance

To determine the nature of respiratory functional impairment caused by asbestos-induced visceral pleural fibrosis (VPF) and to discover which pulmonary physiological variable best reveals it, we examined 59 asbestos-exposed construction workers having asbestos-related changes on chest radiographs. Computed tomography scans of the thorax were also performed. Visceral pleural fibrosis was diagnosed in 29 subjects: seven had only VPF, 17 had VPF and pleural plaques, and five had VPF, plaques, and asbestosis. In subjects without VPF, 23 had plaques, six had plaques and asbestosis, and one had only minor fibrotic parenchymal changes insufficient for a diagnosis of asbestosis. Flow-volume spirometry, body plethysmography, static and dynamic compliance, and pulmonary diffusing capacity for carbon monoxide were measured. The subjects with VPF had significantly lower static (p = 0.005) and dynamic (p = 0.007) compliance values than those without. Other respiratory function variables failed to show any significant differences. We conclude that the measurement of static and dynamic compliance is a useful method in assessing pulmonary function impairment caused by visceral pleural fibrosis.     

Abnormal pulmonary function associated with diaphragmatic pleural plaques due to exposure to asbestos

Pulmonary function was measured in 79 men with diaphragmatic pleural plaques (DPP) as the only abnormality characteristic of asbestos disease on chest radiographs. They were selected from 4572 construction and shipyard workers exposed to asbestos. Abnormalities of pulmonary function in 21 non-smokers and 43 current smokers were compared with referent values adjusted for height, age, and duration of cigarette smoking. In the non-smokers, flows (FEV1) FEF75-85 and FEV1/FVC) were reduced and TGV and RV/TGV were raised. Current smokers had similar significant reductions. Thus by contrast with some current opinion that plaques are "an index only of past asbestos exposure," workers with plaques, even limited to the diaphragm, have functional impairment typical of pulmonary asbestosis. This suggests that they have pulmonary asbestosis, which is below the threshold of radiographic recognition.     

Lung cinescintigraphy in the dynamic assessment of ventilation and mucociliary clearance of asbestos cement workers.

OBJECTIVES: To verify in vivo whether lung cinescintigraphy confirms the effect of asbestos on the patency of the smallest airways and on the efficiency of mucociliary clearance in asbestos cement workers. METHODS: 39 male subjects were examined: 30 asbestos cement workers and nine workers never exposed to occupational respiratory irritants. All subjects had a chest radiograph (International Labour Organisation (ILO) 1980); standard questionnaire on chronic bronchitis; spirometry; arterial blood gas analysis; carbon monoxide transfer factor (TLcosb); pulmonary O2 and CO2 ductances (DuO2, DuCO2); electrocardiogram; and lung cinescintigraphy after radioaerosol inhalation for the measurement of mucociliary clearance time in vivo in the smallest ciliated airways and for the assessment of radioaerosol deposition in alveoli (alveolar deposition index). RESULTS: Apart from nine non-exposed subjects, the 30 asbestos cement workers were so classified on the basis of chest radiography: nine of them as healthy exposed, 10 with pleural plaques, and 11 with asbestosis. The four groups had similar ages, work seniority, and smoking habits. Exercise dyspnoea was significantly more frequent in asbestos cement workers. Lung function variables of workers with effects related to asbestos were significantly lower than the other two groups. The PaO2, TLcOsb and DuO2 mean values were significantly lower in exposed workers than non-exposed. The mean PacO2 value was significantly higher in the asbestosis group than in the other three groups. Workers with effects related to asbestos showed a significantly lower alveolar deposition index and a significantly higher mucociliary clearance time than the other two groups. Subjects with asbestosis showed similar differences from those with pleural plaques. CONCLUSIONS: Lung cinescintigraphy confirms in vivo the effects of asbestos on bronchiolar and alveolar patency and on efficiency of mucociliary clearance in the smallest ciliated airways. Finally, lung cinescintigraphic variables are able to discriminate workers with asbestosis from those with pleural plaques.     

The patient with asbestos exposure

Attention to the hazards of asbestos has aroused concern among many healthy persons who have been exposed at some time to one of the world's most versatile materials. Present standards for exposure to asbestos, however, may not fully protect workers from asbestos-induced pulmonary malignancy. To evaluate the patient who has had some asbestos exposure, the physician should focus on the pulmonary system, take a thorough occupational history, conduct a physical examination and pulmonary function studies, and obtain chest films. In managing the patient with asbestosis, removal from further occupational exposure is advisable. For workers with only pleural changes, it is unclear whether removal from the work place is of any value.     

Asbestos-related lesions of the pleura: parietal plaques compared to diffuse thickening studied with chest roentgenography, computed tomography, lung function, and gas exchange

Lung function tests, tests of working capacity with gas exchange, and computed tomography (CT) with density measurements with the patient supine and prone were performed in 23 males with asbestos-related bilateral pleural lesions. Two had pulmonary asbestosis grade 1/0 or more; all the others had normal lung parenchyma. On x-ray, the pleural lesions were divided into plaques involving only the parietal pleura There was a and diffuse pleural fibrosis of various degrees involving the visceral pleura. There was a good correlation between the findings at plain chest roentgenography and CT, but more lesions were seen on the CT scan. However, a few pleural plaques seen on conventional films were not observed at CT. Individuals with plaques had slightly lowered lung function compared to reference subjects. Bilateral diffuse pleural fibrosis was associated with a marked decrease in pulmonary function. The two patients with radiologically evident pulmonary asbestosis were found in this group. Decreased lung function was also observed in subjects with pleural fibrosis of only grade 1 (involving less than one fourth of the hemithorax) and a normal exercise capacity. The study shows the importance of differentiation between various asbestos-related pleural lesions.     

Role of computed tomography in evaluating asbestos related lung disease

To find how computed tomography (CT) may be effectively used in individuals with suspected asbestos related lung disease 30 men with a history of exposure to asbestos were studied. All subjects underwent high kilovoltage posteroanterior and left lateral chest radiographs and chest CT. Eighteen were randomly selected asbestos workers referred for routine surveillance. The remaining 12 were patients who had been referred for investigation of respiratory symptoms or abnormal routine chest radiograph, or both, and found to have chest radiographic changes compatible with asbestos related lung disease. In the group referred for routine surveillance both pleural shadowing and pulmonary shadowing were shown on CT but not chest radiographs in only one case. Five were thought to have pleural shadowing on chest radiographs but this was confirmed on CT in only one case. All 12 patients referred for investigation showed pleural shadowing on chest radiographs; this was confirmed in all cases on CT which also showed unsuspected pulmonary shadowing in five cases. These findings suggest that it is not appropriate to use chest CT routinely in all asbestos workers referred for routine surveillance. When CT is used selectively in those with pleural shadowing on plain chest radiography, however, it is helpful in refuting or confirming the presence of pleural disease and may show unsuspected pulmonary shadowing.     

Role of computed tomography in evaluating asbestos related lung disease.

To find how computed tomography (CT) may be effectively used in individuals with suspected asbestos related lung disease 30 men with a history of exposure to asbestos were studied. All subjects underwent high kilovoltage posteroanterior and left lateral chest radiographs and chest CT. Eighteen were randomly selected asbestos workers referred for routine surveillance. The remaining 12 were patients who had been referred for investigation of respiratory symptoms or abnormal routine chest radiograph, or both, and found to have chest radiographic changes compatible with asbestos related lung disease. In the group referred for routine surveillance both pleural shadowing and pulmonary shadowing were shown on CT but not chest radiographs in only one case. Five were thought to have pleural shadowing on chest radiographs but this was confirmed on CT in only one case. All 12 patients referred for investigation showed pleural shadowing on chest radiographs; this was confirmed in all cases on CT which also showed unsuspected pulmonary shadowing in five cases. These findings suggest that it is not appropriate to use chest CT routinely in all asbestos workers referred for routine surveillance. When CT is used selectively in those with pleural shadowing on plain chest radiography, however, it is helpful in refuting or confirming the presence of pleural disease and may show unsuspected pulmonary shadowing.     

Radiographic assessment of pleuropulmonary disease in asbestos workers: posteroanterior, four view films, and computed tomograms of the thorax.

To study the clinical usefulness of computed tomography (CT) scanning of the thorax in asbestos related pleuropulmonary disease, 127 long term asbestos workers of the mines and mills in the Eastern Townships of Québec were examined. The CT scan was compared with the standard posteroanterior (PA) chest film and the four view films using the ILO grading system for profusion of disease. Six lung areas and six pleural sites were studied. On the basis of the usual diagnostic criteria, 41% of the workers had asbestosis. For profusion of parenchymal disease, there was an excellent correlation (r = 0.96, p less than 0.001) between PA and four view films and the latter did not significantly increase the total profusion score; the CT scan correlated less well with the PA film (r = 0.79, p less than 0.01) and the scatter of the data was larger. In 10 of the 53 (19%) workers with asbestosis the pulmonary lesions were not recognised by CT scan. For profusion of pleural plaques, there was an excellent correlation (p = 0.91, p less than 0.001) between PA and four view films; scores were identical in 73%, higher for PA in 7%, and higher for four view films in 19%. CT scan scores, however, were identical with PA films in 31%, higher for CT scan in 13% (owing to higher scores on lateral pleural sites), and lower for CT scan in 56% (owing to lower scores at diaphragm and costophrenic angle sites). Pleural calcifications were identified in 24 workers for a total of 40 sites; 13 as possible, 31% identified by two modes, and 27 as definite. Of the latter, 14 were seen only on CT scan. In the workers with rigid pressure volume curve of the lung and increased Gallium-67 lung uptake only, CT scan total scores were not significantly higher than in those without these markers of early interstitial lung disease (5 +/- 1 v 4 +/- 1, p less than 0.05). Thus the four view films and CT scan appear to be useful mainly in the assessment of pleural disease. The four view film identifies more sites of pleural plaques and the CT scan more pleural calcified plaques.     

Railways and asbestos in Japan (1928-1987)--epidemiology of pleural plaques, malignancies and pneumoconioses-

Asbestos has been an indispensable insulating material for railway industries, especially steam locomotives (SLs). This review (1928-1987) consists of three parts. 1) Pleural plaques: Since the 1970s, pleural plaques have been regarded as evidence of past asbestos inhalation, and more recently recognized as a risk factor of asbestos-related malignancies. For diagnostic criteria on plain radiographs, the modified ILO 1980 International Classification of Radiographs of Pneumoconioses was used. Most cases had pleural plaques with normal lungs. Large plant workers showed a significantly higher rate of plaques than workers in smaller plants. Bilateral plaques were dominant followed by the left, then the right lung, and chest wall plaques were dominant over the diaphragm. The manifestation of pleural plaques was more correlated to years since the onset of the asbestos exposure than the sum of asbestos work years, although the result was not significant. The boilermen of railway ferry steamers had a significantly higher plaque rate than other seamen. CT studies on plaques started in 1978. 2) Asbestos-related malignancies: Five retrospective cohort studies 1960-1970 were made on primary lung cancer incidence and mortality among 350,000 active railway men with smoking information. The follow-up period was 20 yr at the longest. Almost all plant workers showed a tendency of higher incidence or mortality than the controls. Two cases of mesothelioma were reported in 1980. 3) Pneumoconioses: Most studies (1928-1975) had relatively low prevalence rates among SL-related workers.     

石棉工人肺功能与X射线胸片变化关系的研究

目的 探讨石棉工人肺功能与X射线胸片变化之间的关系。为早期发现石棉肺和对石棉肺患者肺代偿功能评价提供客观依据。方法 接触组为某温石棉制品厂134名男工，对照组为同一地区不接触粉尘，劳动强度与研究组工人大体相似的某仪表厂135名男工，对肺功能测定和X射线胸片检查结果进行对比分析。结果 胸膜和肺组织均有纤维化者，肺功能均明显下降。呈混合性肺功能障碍的特点；弥漫性胸膜增厚则与FVC，FEV1.0,FEV1.0/FVC%,DLco和Kco均呈显著负相关（r值分别为-0.20,-0.26,-0.21,-0.27,-0.19)。单纯胸膜斑与Kco呈正相关（r=0.23)；胸膜病变范围越大，肺功能损害也越严重。呈限制性肺功能障碍的特征。结论 石棉工人肺代偿功能指标的异常。可以早期反映肺内纤维化和胸膜病变的程度和范围。     

Asbestos-related pleural plaques and lung function

The present study examines the association between asbestos-related pleural plaques and lung function in a group of workers with occupational exposure to asbestos. Exposure, smoking, and respiratory histories, chest radiographs, flow-volume loops, and single breath DLCOs were obtained on 383 railroad workers. A score based on the ILO-1980 classification system was used to quantify the extent of plaquelike thickening. In order to eliminate potential confounders, we excluded from final analysis subjects with diffuse pleural thickening (n = 10) or small irregular opacities classified as profusion 0/1 or greater (n = 6) on chest radiograph. Definite pleural plaques were observed in 22.6%. The single breath DLCO was similar in the groups with and without plaques (p = 0.0550). Decrement in FVC and the occurrence of pulmonary restriction were associated with the presence of definite plaques (p = 0.0306 and 0.0431, respectively) and with quantitative pleural score (p = 0.0135 and 0.0126), controlling for duration of asbestos exposure and smoking. A test for trend revealed an association between level of diagnostic certainty (none, suspect, definite) for pleural plaques and these measures of lung function (p less than 0.02). Our findings reveal an association between asbestos-related pleural plaques and decrement in lung function as measured by FVC and criteria for pulmonary restriction.     

Asbestos content of lung tissue and carcinoma of the lung: a clinicopathologic correlation and mineral fiber analysis of 234 cases

The aim of this study was to investigate the asbestos content of lung tissue in a series of patients with lung cancer and some history of asbestos exposure. This information was then correlated with demographic information, occupational and smoking history, presence or absence of pathologic asbestosis or pleural plaques, and pathologic features of the cancer. The pulmonary concentration of asbestos fibers in 234 cases of primary carcinoma of the lung was determined by means of a tissue digestion technique. Asbestos body counts were performed in 229 cases and fiber analysis by scanning electron microscopy in 221 cases. Asbestos content was recorded as total asbestos fibers, commercial amphibole fibers, noncommercial amphibole fibers, and chrysotile fibers 5 microm or greater in length per gram of wet lung tissue. The study group included 70 patients with asbestosis (Group I), 44 patients with parietal pleural plaques but without asbestosis (Group II), and 120 patients with neither (Group III). The median asbestos body content of Group I was more than 35 times greater than Group II and more than 300 times greater than Group III. The total asbestos fiber count for Group I was nearly 20 times greater than Group II and more than 50 times greater than Group III. The difference was due almost entirely to commercial amphiboles.In a series of primary lung cancer cases with some history of asbestos exposure, a markedly elevated asbestos content was identified among those with pathologic asbestosis as compared with patients with pleural plaques alone or with neither plaques nor asbestosis.     

High-resolution computed tomography abnormalities in ex-insulators annually exposed to asbestos dust

BACKGROUND: characterize To the effects of high asbestos exposure during annual periods of insulation. METHOD: 170 ex-workers underwent clinical examination, spirometry, standard chest X-rays and high-resolution computed tomography (HRCT). Asbestos exposure was retrospectively assessed for latency, duration, and intensity. RESULTS: Sixty-six percent of these workers were annually exposed to high concentrations of asbestos dust. Respiratory symptoms were mild. One hundred and nineteen subjects had pleural or pulmonary changes on HRCT, compatible with asbestos exposure. Localized pleural thickening was found in 113 subjects (66.5%); pulmonary nodules or lines in 35 (20.6%). The presence of pleural plaques was linked to intensity of asbestos exposure (P <.01), and length of employment (P <.05). Parenchymal lesions were related to intensity (P <.05) and duration of exposure (P <.05). Lung function of subjects with X-ray changes was not significantly altered. CONCLUSIONS: Annual asbestos exposure led to a high prevalence of pleural plaques and to mild parenchymal anomalies.     

CT检查在石棉肺诊断中的价值

目的　研究石棉肺的肺实质和胸膜病变的ＣＴ 检查所见。方法　对１９ 例石棉肺患者进行胸部Ｘ 线和ＣＴ 检查, 比较Ｘ 线和ＣＴ 检查对石棉肺患者肺实质改变和胸膜改变的表现特点和检出结果。结果　Ｘ 线胸片有胸膜改变的５例, 其中１ 例为胸膜斑。ＣＴ 检查发现有胸膜改变的１６ 例, 其中６ 例为胸膜斑; ６ 例有胸膜斑的病例中, 有３ 例为Ｘ 线胸片上难以发现的脊椎旁胸膜斑。肺实质改变, 在Ｘ 线胸片上, 在３ 个病例各发现１ 个大阴影; 而ＣＴ 检查, 在４ 个病例中, 共发现５ 个大阴影, 其中１ 例伴有胸膜下曲线状肺纤维化阴影。肺内小阴影的显示, ＣＴ 检查所见不如Ｘ 线所见的密集。结论　联合应用胸部Ｘ 线和ＣＴ 检查结果, 可为石棉肺的诊断和分级提供较有价值的信息。     

Malignant mesothelioma from neighborhood exposure to anthophyllite asbestos

BACKGROUND: Anthophyllite asbestos has been reported to cause asbestosis, lung cancer, mesothelioma, and pleural plaques in occupationally exposed workers. Anthophyllite has also been associated with pleural plaques in Finland and Japan among those who live near mines and mills and have neighborhood or environmental exposure. METHODS: We evaluated a 38-year-old patient with pleural mesothelioma who lived, attended school, and delivered newspapers near a manufacturing facility that used exclusively anthophyllite asbestos fiber from ages 8-17 years. He had no work exposure to asbestos. RESULTS: The pleural mesothelioma was an epithelial type with tubulopapillary structures and was treated with an extrapleural pneumonectomy followed by radiation therapy. The malignant cells were positive by immunohistochemistry for cytokeratin but negative for carcinoembryonic antigen, S100, B72.3, and leu M1 antigen. Anthophyllite fibers were > 5 microm in length in lung tissue compared to 3 microm from a general population study. CONCLUSIONS: Anthophyllite asbestos has been associated with neighborhood environmental exposure and pleural plaques; we now report a neighborhood exposure and pleural mesothelioma.     

Pleural thickening: a comparison of oblique chest radiographs and high-resolution computed tomography in subjects exposed to low levels of asbestos pollution

Summary The present study was conducted to investigate the value of oblique chest radiographs, compared with high-resolution computed tomography (HRCT), in the assessment of pleural asbestosis in a group of subjects exposed to low levels of asbestos pollution. The study population consisted of 23 people derived from a previously reported cohort of subjects working in university buildings insulated with asbestos-containing material. Subjects were selected on a voluntary basis from among patients whose initial oblique chest X-rays showed pleural thickening. Sixteen patients were maintenance workers occupationally exposed to asbestos; the remaining seven were environmentally exposed to asbestos. For each subject, two standard chest radiographs [posteroanterior (PA) and right anterior oblique (RAO) views] were taken and HRCT was performed. Films were interpreted after agreement by three chest physicians and a radiologist. Pleural thickening was considered present in all 23 patients on RAO films and in six patients on PA films. HRCT revealed unequivocal pleural plaques in three maintenance workers and doubtful pleural abnormalities in three other maintenance workers. Considering HRCT as the gold standard, the positive predictive value of RAO film was only 13%–26%. Most of the 17 false-positive diagnoses of pleural fibrosis were due to significant subpleural fat. These results suggest that the routine use of oblique radiographs as a screening test in cohorts of subjects exposed to low levels of pollution by asbestos should be reevaluated.     

Incremental value of oblique chest radiographs in the diagnosis of asbestos-induced pleural disease

To assess the value of oblique chest radiographs in the diagnosis of asbestos-related pleural disease, we identified 100 asbestos-exposed construction workers and provided separate interpretations of the postero-anterior (PA), left anterior oblique (LAO), and right anterior oblique (RAO) projections using the International Labour Office (ILO) system. We found that the LAO projection identified left-sided pleural thickening more effectively than the PA view and the RAO view improved diagnosis of right-sided disease comparably. Of 62 cases of bilateral pleural thickening, only 43 (68%) were diagnosed by the PA projection alone. The increased diagnostic efficiency of approximately 50% in identifying bilateral pleural thickening appears to justify the routine use of oblique chest films in screening asbestos-exposed populations. Since bilateral pleural thickening among asbestos-exposed workers is an indicator of significant asbestos exposure and increased risk of other asbestos-induced conditions, early detection of this abnormality can lead to interventions designed to reduce asbestos-related morbidity and mortality.