Effect of Deploying Trained Community Based Reproductive Health Nurses (CORN) on Long‐Acting Reversible Contraception (LARC) Use in Rural Ethiopia: A Cluster Randomized Community Trial

To investigate the effect of innovative means to distribute LARC on contraceptive use, we implemented a three arm, parallel groups, cluster randomized community trial design. The intervention consisted of placing trained community‐based reproductive health nurses (CORN) within health centers or health posts. The nurses provided counseling to encourage women to use LARC and distributed all contraceptive methods. A total of 282 villages were randomly selected and assigned to a control arm (n = 94) or 1 of 2 treatment arms (n = 94 each). The treatment groups differed by where the new service providers were deployed, health post or health center. We calculated difference‐in‐difference (DID) estimates to assess program impacts on LARC use. After nine months of intervention, the use of LARC methods increased significantly by 72.3 percent, while the use of short acting methods declined by 19.6 percent. The proportion of women using LARC methods increased by 45.9 percent and 45.7 percent in the health post and health center based intervention arms, respectively. Compared to the control group, the DID estimates indicate that the use of LARC methods increased by 11.3 and 12.3 percentage points in the health post and health center based intervention arms. Given the low use of LARC methods in similar settings, deployment of contextually trained nurses at the grassroots level could substantially increase utilization of these methods.     

Postpartum and Post‐Abortion Contraception: From Research to Programs

Contraception following delivery or an induced abortion reduces the risk of an early unintended pregnancy and its associated adverse health consequences. Unmet need for contraception during the postpartum period and contraceptive counseling and services following abortion have been the focus of efforts for the last several decades. This article provides an introduction to the more focused contributions that follow in this special issue. We discuss the validity and measurement of the concept of unmet need for family planning during the postpartum period. We then present key findings on postpartum contraceptive protection, use dynamics, and method mix, followed by an assessment of interventions to improve postpartum family planning. The evidence on postabortion contraceptive uptake and continuation of use remains thin, although encouraging results are noted for implementation of comprehensive abortion care and for the impact of post‐abortion contraceptive counseling and services. Drawing on these studies, we outline policy and program implications for improving postpartum and post‐abortion contraceptive use.     

Long-term effects of a community-based program on contraceptive use among sexually active unmarried youth in Shanghai, China.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the long-term (48-month) sustainable effect of a set of community-based interventions to promote contraceptive use among sexually active unmarried youth in suburban Shanghai, China. METHODS: A nonrandomized community trial with one intervention and one control group was conducted in two comparable towns of a suburban area of Shanghai. The intervention program was developed and implemented to increase knowledge and access to sexual and reproductive health services among unmarried youth aged 15-24 years. Baseline surveys were conducted in both sites before implementation of the intervention, and similar surveys were conducted in both sites 20 months after the launch of the intervention and 28 months after the end of the intervention. RESULTS: Statistically significant differences between the respondents surveyed at baseline in 2000 and at the long-term follow up in 2004 were observed in some age categories and in some educational groups. In the postproject period, there was a major improvement in all indicators in the control group. Among the sub-set of respondents interviewed both in 2000 and 2004 who were exposed to the intervention program, the interventions were associated with a significant increase in the frequency of contraceptive use among participants initiating sexual relations over the period of the intervention (odds ratio [OR] = 6.91), as well as with significant reduction in use ever of the withdrawal method of contraception among all sexually active respondents (OR = .37) compared with the control group during long-term follow-up period. No long-term effects on contraceptive practice were observed among new respondents who were not exposed to the intervention program. CONCLUSIONS: Comprehensive community-based interventions appear to have limited long-term effects on contraceptive use among unmarried youth in suburban Shanghai. It is necessary to provide sex and reproductive health education and services to all unmarried young people on a regular basis.     

Associations Between Abortion Services and Acceptance of Postabortion Contraception in Six Indian States

Women receiving induced abortions or postabortion care are at high risk of subsequent unintended pregnancy, and intervals of less than six months between abortion and subsequent pregnancy may be associated with adverse outcomes. This study highlights the prevalence and attributes of postabortion contraceptive acceptance from 2,456 health facilities in six major Indian states, among 292,508 women who received abortion care services from July 2011 through June 2014. Eighty‐one percent of the women accepted postabortion contraceptive methods: 53 percent short‐term, 11 percent intrauterine devices, and 16 percent sterilization. Postabortion contraceptive acceptance was highest among women who were aged 25 years and older, received first‐trimester services, received induced abortion, attended primary‐level health facilities, and had medical abortions. Doctors receiving post‐training support were more likely to offer contraceptives, but no association was observed between such support and acceptance of IUDs or sterilization. Comprehensive service‐delivery interventions, including ensuring availability of skilled providers and contraceptive commodities, offering clinical mentoring for providers, identifying and addressing provider bias, and improving provider counseling skills, can increase postabortion contraceptive acceptance and reduce unintended pregnancy.     

The influence of health care on contraceptive acceptance in rural Mexico

This paper offers two types of evidence in support of the idea that family planning services are most expediently provided as an integral part of the health and medical organization for maternity care. First, prenatal care and medical attention at delivery are found to be closely associated with postpartum contraceptive acceptance in a 1981 survey of family planning in rural Mexico. Second, interviews of a sample of doctors, nurses, and auxiliaries who provide maternal health services to the rural population reveal that these practitioners favor long birth intervals and small completed families, that they recommend the use of modern contraceptive methods including female sterilization, and that those in the employ of public institutions are motivated to recruit acceptors of these methods. The main impediment to contraceptive acceptance in this context is believed to be fear of side effects and permanent health consequences rather than the desire for additional children.     

The influence of nurse home visits, including provision of 3 months of contraceptives and contraceptive counseling, on perceived barriers to contraceptive use and contraceptive use self-efficacy

OBJECTIVE: To identify the influence of a community health nurse (CHN) home visit on perceived barriers to contraceptive access and contraceptive use self-efficacy. METHODS: We enrolled 103 women into two groups in a randomized trial evaluating the influence of contraceptive dispensing and family planning counseling during home visits on perceived barriers to accessing contraceptives and contraceptive use self-efficacy. Both groups received counseling by a CHN about sexually transmitted disease and pregnancy prevention, and a resource card listing phone numbers of family planning clinics. After randomization, the CHN dispensed three months of hormonal contraception to the intensive intervention group and advised the minimal intervention group to schedule an appointment at a family planning clinic. Data collection at baseline and 12 months included demographic, reproductive and other health-related information as well as quantitative assessments of information on perceived barriers to contraceptive access and contraceptive use self-efficacy. RESULTS: The mean age of participants was 24.7 years. Three-fourths had household incomes under $25,000. We found significant reductions in three perceived barriers to contraceptive access for both groups, as well as significant increases in two measures of contraceptive use self-efficacy at twelve months compared to baseline. CONCLUSION: Nurse home visits involving family planning counseling might be effective in reducing perceived barriers to contraceptive access and increasing contraceptive use self-efficacy.     

Evaluation of an Integrated Services Program to Prevent Subsequent Pregnancy and Birth Among Urban Teen Mothers

This article details the evaluation of a clinical services program for teen mothers in the District of Columbia. The program's primary objectives are to prevent unintended subsequent pregnancy and to promote contraceptive utilization. We calculated contraceptive utilization at 6, 12, 18, and 24 months after delivery, as well as occurrence of subsequent pregnancy and birth. Nearly seven in ten (69.5%) teen mothers used contraception at 24 months after delivery, and 57.1% of contraceptive users elected long-acting reversible contraception. In the 24-month follow-up period, 19.3% experienced at least one subsequent pregnancy and 8.0% experienced a subsequent birth. These results suggest that an integrated clinical services model may contribute to sustained contraceptive use and may prove beneficial in preventing subsequent teen pregnancy and birth.     

Health and safety intervention with first-time mothers

A health education program was evaluated which used child development specialists as home visitors and served a population of first-time mothers living in rural communities. The evaluation compared health and safety outcomes between intervention and control groups. The research staff, separate from the intervention staff, collected data in the homes of 156 intervention and 107 control mothers when the infants were 6 and 12 months old. Significant group differences were found on health and safety outcomes. As compared with controls, the intervention mothers (i) had safer homes; (ii) were more likely to use birth control, thus had fewer pregnancies since birth of their first child; (iii) reported smoking fewer cigarettes; (iv) knew more about effects of smoking on their child's health and (v) were more likely to use health department services. In sum, mothers who received early education home visits from child development specialists experienced positive health and safety outcomes. It is highly recommended that a program such as this be implemented as part of health delivery program with new mothers and infants.     

A breast-feeding promotion and support program a randomized trial in The Netherlands

BACKGROUND: In the Netherlands, the initiation rate of breast-feeding (BF) was 80% in 2002, but only 35% of the mothers continued to breast-feed for 3 months. This study examined the effectiveness of a breast-feeding promotion program to increase the continuation of breast-feeding. METHODS: A cluster-randomized intervention trial was used. Ten child health care centers in three regions of the home health care were randomly allocated to the program or usual care. Elements in the program were health counseling, measures to enhance cooperation, early signaling of breast-feeding problems and continuity of care, and lactation consultancy. Pregnant mothers who applied for home health care in the intervention or usual care regions were enrolled and were followed up from pregnancy until 6 months postpartum (n = 683). The primary outcome measure was the continuation of breast-feeding until at least 3 months. RESULTS: The 3-month breast-feeding rate was 32% in the intervention and 38% in the control groups (OR = 0.79, 95% CI = 0.58-1.08). CONCLUSION: The program was not effective. We discuss possible explanations from the design and execution of the trial and give some points for improvement of our program, such as the categories of caregivers involved and the number and duration of contacts after parturition.     

An Assessment of the Use and Impact of Ancillary Prenatal Care Services to Medicaid Women in Managed Care

Objectives: Managed care plans under Medicaid are becoming a usual source of care for low-income pregnant women. This study describes an ancillary prenatal care service intervention developed by one managed care organization (MCO) for Medicaid-enrolled women, assesses the extent to which the intervention services were used, and appraises the influence of the intervention on prenatal care participation. Method: There were 226 intervention and 258 control women with a single live birth delivered between 28 and 44 weeks gestation who (1) were enrolled in the MCO's Medicaid program, (2) were high-risk based on a prenatal risk assessment, and (3) started prenatal care prior to 26 weeks gestation. Less than adequate and intensive prenatal care utilization were chosen as intervention outcomes measures. Results: Family planning, a 2-month postpartum baby visit, a maternal postpartum visit, and a WIC (Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children) referral were among the most self-selected intervention services for this population; home health aide and breast-feeding support were the least requested services. Over 90% of those needing family planning or breast-feeding services received the services, while over 20% of the intervention group refused child care, food assistance and family violence referrals, and home health aide and smoking cessation services. The intervention group had a significantly lower risk of less than adequate utilization of prenatal care (OR = .32; 95% CI: 0.17–0.60) and was more likely to have an intensive number of prenatal care visits (OR = 1.61; 95% CI: 1.05–2.48). Conclusions: The ability of managed care organizations to provide ongoing prenatal care to Medicaid populations in a cost-effective manner depends partly on their development of packages of prenatal services that foster positive preventive health care utilization behaviors and good pregnancy outcomes. The results of this project suggest that the intervention was beneficial in the area of improving utilization of prenatal care.     

Mobilizing demand for contraception in rural Gambia

A community trial was conducted in rural Gambia in order to determine whether a community-based intervention designed to mobilize latent demand for contraception would increase use of modern contraceptives, even in the absence of improved availability of family planning services. Analysis of trial data indicates that the demand-mobilization intervention had a statistically significant positive effect on nonusers' adoption of modern contraception and that coterminous implementation of an intervention designed to improve access to services offered no additional benefit. The program component found to have the greatest impact was the "kabilo approach," in which village women provide basic health and family planning counseling to other women in their extended families. These results suggest that the principal barriers to increased contraceptive use in rural Gambia are psychosocial and that these barriers can be overcome through village-based interventions designed to provide socially appropriate counseling to potential contraceptive users.     

上海市中心城区产后妇女避孕需求及产后避孕服务利用调查

目的调查上海市中心城区产后妇女避孕节育现况及避孕相关生殖健康服务利用情况。方法2019年8月至12月期间,采用横断面调查的方法对在上海市4个区(长宁区、静安区、普陀区、杨浦区)产后42 d健康检查门诊就诊和前往儿童保健门诊的妇女进行问卷调查。数据分析采用频率和logistic回归分析等方法。结果调查的1170名产后妇女中有420名已恢复性生活,恢复时间为分娩后(3.6±1.5)个月。按照产后时间不同进行分组,已恢复性生活的调查对象在产后1~3个月、4~6个月、7~9个月和10~12个月坚持采用避孕措施的比例分别为69.4%(43/62)、77.2%(186/241)、79.2%(57/72)和71.1%(32/45)。是否计划妊娠、再生育意愿以及产后避孕指导是影响避孕行为的主要因素。产后不同时期的妇女采用的避孕方法均以避孕套为主,长效可逆避孕方法使用率低。在产后访视和产后42 d检查时分别有43.3%(395/913)和34.6%(369/1067)的调查对象获得了具体的避孕方法指导。37.6%(420/1117)的调查对象认为产后42 d检查是避孕最佳健康宣教时机,而30.5%(341/1117)的妇女认为孕期健康教育时就应该给予指导。结论约四分之一的上海市中心城区妇女在产后未坚持采用避孕措施;宫内节育器、皮下埋植剂等长效、可逆的避孕方法使用率低。应加强产后避孕指导,强化专业队伍培训,重视避孕药具的正确选择和使用,引导妇女正确认识长效避孕方法。同时,避孕指导服务可提前至孕期开展,做到关口前移。     

Correlates of short interbirth intervals in Peninsular Malaysia: their pathways of influence through breastfeeding and contraceptive use

Recent research has shown that children born before and after short birth intervals run a considerably greater risk of dying in infancy or childhood than do others. This report investigates which women have short interbirth intervals, under what circumstances, and for what reasons. The analysis uses data from the Malaysian Family Life Survey to examine influences on the two main behaviors--breastfeeding and contraceptive use--that affect birth interval length, and assesses the the impact of these same variables on the probability of having a birth interval of less than 15 months. The analysis shows that many of the independent variables affect breastfeeding and contraceptive use in opposite directions, with no significant net effect on the likelihood of a short interval. For example, a woman's education is negatively related to the probability that she breastfeeds, positively related to the probability that she uses contraceptives, and has no significant effect on the likelihood that the interpregnancy interval is less than 15 months. Having a family planning clinic nearby is associated with less breastfeeding, offsetting whatever positive effects family planning clinics have on contraceptive use in terms of the percentage of birth intervals that are so short as to be detrimental to infant and child health. Hence, factors that increase contraceptive use do not necessarily reduce the incidence of short interbirth intervals, because they are also associated with reduced breastfeeding. We simulate the proportion of intervals that would be short for alternative combinations of breastfeeding and contraceptive use in the population and show that over the period covered by the data (1961-75), breastfeeding had a considerably greater effect on preventing short interbirth intervals than did contraceptive use.     

Use of multiple opportunities for improving feeding practices in under-twos within child health programmes

Objectives: In a community randomized trial, we aimed to promoteexclusive breastfeeding and appropriate complementary feedingpractices in under-twos to ascertain the feasibility of usingavailable channels for nutrition counselling, their relativeperformance and the relationship between intensity of counsellingand behaviour change. We also assessed whether using multipleopportunities to impart nutrition education adversely affectedroutine activities. Methods: We conducted a community randomized, controlled effectivenesstrial in rural Haryana, India, with four intervention and fourcontrol communities. We trained health and nutrition workersin the intervention communities to counsel mothers at multiplecontacts on breastfeeding exclusively for 6 months and on appropriatecomplementary feeding practices thereafter. The interventionwas not just training health and nutrition workers in counsellingbut included community and health worker mobilization. Findings: In the intervention group, about 32% of caregiverswere counselled by traditional birth attendants at birth. Themost frequent sources of counselling from birth to 3 monthswere immunization sessions (45.1%) and home visits (32.1%),followed closely by weighing sessions (25.5%); from 7 to 12months, home visits (42.6%) became more important than the othertwo. An increase in the number of channels through which caregiverswere counselled was positively associated with exclusive breastfeedingprevalence at 3 months (p = 0.002), consumption of milk/cerealgruel or mix use at 9 months (p = 0.004) and 18 months (p =0.003), undiluted milk at 9 months (p<0.0001) and 24 hournon-breast-milk energy intakes at 18 months (p = 0.023), aftercontrolling for potential confounding factors. Interventionareas, compared with the control, had higher coverage for vitaminA (45% vs. 11.5%) and iron folic acid (45% vs. 0.4%) supplementation. Conclusions: Using multiple available opportunities and workersfor counselling caregivers was feasible, resulted in high coverageand impact, and instead of disrupting ongoing services, resultedin their improvement.     

A randomized controlled trial of the effect of advanced supply of emergency contraception in postpartum teens: a feasibility study

Background

The study was conducted to test the feasibility of conducting a randomized controlled contraceptive trial in postpartum teens and to assess whether postpartum advanced supply of emergency contraception (EC) to teenaged mothers helps to prevent repeat pregnancies of close proximity.

Study Design

We performed a randomized controlled trial of 50 postpartum teens at an urban academic medical center. Participants in the intervention arm received routine postpartum contraceptive care and advanced supply of one pack of EC pills with unlimited supply thereafter upon request. The routine care arm (RCA) received routine postpartum contraceptive care. We asked open-ended questions about how we might maximize study retention and implemented the participants' requests in both arms.

Results

Our retention rate was 78%. There were three (13%) pregnancies out of 23 participants in the intervention arm and eight (30%) pregnancies out of 27 participants in the RCA. The risk of pregnancy occurring in the intervention arm was 0.57 times that of the RCA (95% CI 0.20-1.60; p=.23).

Conclusions

A randomized controlled trial of postpartum teens to receive and not to receive advanced supply of EC is both feasible and necessary. Our study provides preliminary data to suggest that advanced supply of EC may help decrease repeat teen pregnancies.     

Effectiveness of a theory-based postpartum sexual health education program on women's contraceptive use: a randomized controlled trial

Background

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of a refined theory-based Interactive Postpartum Sexual Health Education Program to enhance postpartum women's effective contraceptive behavior.

Study Design

Participants (N=250) were randomized to three groups. Experimental Group A received our intervention program via strategies that matched participants' learning preparedness, as determined by the transtheoretical model. Experimental Group B received only a pamphlet. The control group received routine education. Only Group A received health education. Data were collected at baseline, 3 days, 2 months and 3 months postpartum.

Results

Women who received theory-based postpartum sexual health education program had significantly greater contraceptive self-efficacy and were more likely to choose more effective contraceptive methods at 2 months postpartum than women in the routine teaching and interactive pamphlet-only groups.

Conclusion

Our theory-based Interactive Postpartum Sexual Health Education Program enhanced postpartum women's contraceptive self-efficacy and effective contraceptive behavior.     

State efforts to expand Medicaid-funded family planning show promise

The US government provides 90% of the cost of family planning (FP) services to people eligible for Medicaid, while states contribute the rest and set eligibility ceilings. In the past, only families on welfare received Medicaid, but broader eligibility criteria were created to cover low-income pregnant ("expansion") women until 60 days postpartum, and several states received waivers to extend services beyond this limit. Eight states offer expansion women an additional 2-5 years of FP services, one state offers FP services for 2 years to all women losing regular Medicaid, and four states extend FP services to all low-income women not previously covered by Medicaid. In addition, California provides solely state-funded FP services to women and men with incomes below 200% of the poverty level. Some of these approaches pose outreach challenges, and states have adopted different strategies to extend eligibility to the target population. Data on program enrollment indicate that the state efforts have the potential to reach large numbers of women and to support the work of nonprofit FP clinics. The next step, to expand the program to other states, would be facilitated if Congress obviated the need for states to seek an expansion waiver. Rhode Island's program quickly improved birth intervals for women with Medicaid-funded births so that they were virtually identical to those of privately-insured women and prevented 1443 Medicaid-eligible deliveries, saving $14.3 million through a program that cost $5.7 million from 1994 to 1997.     

Effectiveness of public health nurse home visits to primarous mothers and their infants.

The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of public health nurse postpartum home visits by comparing the health outcomes of 67 randomly selected mother-infant pairs who had received such services with 43 randomly selected mother-infant pairs who had not received them. Health outcome variables were mother's health and health services utilization, infant's health and health services utilization, and mother's parenting practices. Data were collected from birth certificates, health service records, and by home interviews and observations at six months postpartum. No significant differences were noted between home-visited and not-home-visited mother-infant pairs for the majority of health outcome variables. Major, differential health assets and liabilities between groups of Black and White mother-infant pairs were observed.