A comparison of hepatitis C virus (HCV) RNA and – antibody as markers of infection and predictors of infectivity

Background: The diagnosis of hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection currently relies on the detection of antibody to HCV (anti-HCV). However, anti-HCV positivity may indicate past infection, current infection or possibly non-specific reactivity. For confirmation of current infection the virus needs to be assayed directly and this is possible by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Aims: The aims were to compare HCV RNA and anti-HCV as markers of infection in two groups of individuals: (i) a heterogeneous group with suspected HCV infection and (ii) a small group of blood and bone marrow donors, and their respective recipients. Methods: Serum samples were tested for alanine aminotransferase (ALT) as part of a liver function screen, for anti-HCV by ELISAII, and HCV RNA was detected by PCR. Single round and nested PCR was performed using primers designed from the sequence of the 5′-untranslated region of the HCV genome. Results: Of the 36 subjects in the heterogeneous group, 19/22 anti-HCV-positive patients with chronic non-A non-B hepatitis (NANBH) were viraemic, and the majority (17/19) demonstrated elevated ALT. However, HCV RNA was undetected in seven anti-HCV-positive patients, four of whom suffered autoimmune hepatitis Type I and three were low risk blood donors. Of the remaining subjects (seven/36) who were anti-HCV-negative, three/seven were HCV-RNA-positive and included two with acute post-transfusion (PT) NANBH and a recent needlestick victim who contracted HCV. In the second group, four individuals (donors), including a mother with a history of drug use, were implicated in transmission to three recipients. ALT levels were normal in all donors but raised in two of the recipients. PCR determined which of two anti-HCV-negative blood donors was infectious, confirmed transmission between a bone marrow donor and recipient, and indicated that anti-HCV detected in a newborn child represented passive transfer of antibody. Conclusions: Anti-HCV detected by ELISA II is a useful marker of chronic HCV infection, particularly in association with raised ALT. However, HCV RNA is a superior marker of acute HCV infection, a more reliable predictor of infectivity and is more specific.