Caries-preventive effect of anti-erosive and nano-hydroxyapatite-containing toothpastes in vitro

Objectives

The aim of the study was to investigate the caries-preventive effect of newly developed fluoride and fluoride-free toothpastes specially designed for erosion prevention. The hypothesis was that these products might also show superior caries-inhibiting effect than regular fluoride toothpastes, since they were designed for stronger erosive acid challenges.

Materials and methods

Enamel specimens were obtained from bovine teeth and pre-demineralized (pH = 4.95/21 days) to create artificial caries lesions. Baseline mineral loss (ΔZ_B) and lesion depth (LD_B) were determined using transversal microradiography (TMR). Ninety specimens with a median ΔZ_B (SD) of 6027 ± 1546 vol% × μm were selected and randomly allocated to five groups (n = 18). Treatments during pH-cycling (14 days, 4 × 60 min demineralization/day) were brushing 2×/day with AmF (1400 ppm F⁻, anti-caries AC]); AmF/NaF/SnCl₂/Chitosan (700 ppm F⁻/700 ppm F⁻/3500 ppm Sn²⁺, anti-erosion AE1]); NaF/KNO₃ (1400 ppm F⁻, anti-erosion AE2]); nano-hydroxyapatite-containing (0 ppm F⁻, nHA]); and fluoride-free toothpastes (0 ppm F⁻, negative control NC]). Toothpaste slurries were prepared with mineral salt solution (1:3 wt/wt). After pH-cycling specimens presenting lesion, surface loss (mainly by NC and nHA) were discarded. For the remaining 77 specimens, new TMR analyses (ΔZ_E/LD_E) were performed. Changes in mineral loss (ΔΔZ = ΔZ_B − ΔZ_E) and lesion depth (ΔLD = LD_B − LD_E) were calculated.

Results

All toothpastes caused significantly less demineralization (lower ΔΔZ) than NC (p < 0.05, ANOVA) except for nHA. The fluoride toothpastes did not differ significantly regarding ΔΔZ and ΔLD (p > 0.05, ANOVA).

Conclusion/clinical relevance

While both anti-erosive and anti-caries toothpastes reduced mineral loss to a similar extent, the fluoride-free nano-hydroxyapatite-containing toothpaste seemed not to be suitable for inhibition of caries demineralization in vitro.