Chloroquine/hydroxychloroquine: variability of retinotoxic cumulative doses

OBJECTIVE: The critical dose of chloroquine/hydroxychloroquine leading to a maculopathy or generalised retinopathy remains undetermined. In the literature, 100 g is considered the dose at which regular vision checks should be performed. Generally, chloroquine is said to be more toxic than hydroxychloroquine. A young patient presenting with toxic maculopathy after 57 g of hydroxychloroquine and a daily dosage of 2 mg/kg body weight prompted us to retrospectively look at our patients examined in this respect over about 1 year. METHODS: The data of patients who were examined because of chloroquine/hydroxychloroquine intake or a respective maculopathy/retinopathy were retrospectively analysed. The time period was January 2005 until March 2006. Retinal damage was defined by fundus changes and alteration of the multifocal electroretinogram (ERG). RESULTS: Twenty-one patients--18 women and three men--were examined. The mean age was 51 years (range 6-71). Five of the nine chloroquine-treated patients developed a maculopathy, and one of them developed an additional generalised retinopathy. Of the patients treated by hydroxychloroquine, three of 12 suffered from a maculopathy and one from an additional generalised retinopathy. The cumulative doses leading to retinal damage ranged from 170 g to 1650 g for chloroquine and from 57 g to 1190 g for hydroxychloroquine. The highest cumulative doses without leading to signs of retinopathy were 790 g for chloroquine and 1200 g for hydroxychloroquine. CONCLUSIONS: There is a high variability of cumulative doses of chloroquine/hydroxychloroquine that lead to a toxic retinopathy. Therefore, early and regular ophthalmologic examinations are recommended. Electrophysiological testing should be performed once a year, corresponding to about 60 g of base with one tablet a day. For electrophysiology, the multifocal ERG has turned out to be the most important test in this regard. However, visual acuity and funduscopy should be performed more frequently.