Acceptance of Surgery for Obesity by Academic Surgeons in North America

BACKGROUND: Have surgeons in North America accepted operations for the treatment of severe obesity? This question was posed by organizers of the Ninth International Symposium on Obesity Surgery that met in Stockholm in September, 1995. Study design: In order to obtain opinions which might help to answer the question posed, a 1-page questionnaire was sent to 151 chairmen of academic departments of surgery in North America in December 1994 asking about the acceptance and use of surgical operations for the treatment of severe obesity. RESULTS: Answers, received from 112 or 74%, indicated that operative treatment should be used (74%), was effective (77%) and safe (71 %). However, only 65% of departments provided such operations. Operative treatment for obesity was available outside the department in 53%. The operations most frequently used were Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RGB) and vertical banded gastroplasty (VBG). A single operation was offered by 44 departments and a choice of two or more operations in 30 departments. RGB and VBG were equally in use. Gastric banding was used as an alternative to VBG in six departments. Other operations were in use in six departments either alone (three) or as alternatives to RGB and VBG (three). CONCLUSIONS: It appears that surgical treatment of obesity is accepted and available in the majority of academic departments of surgery.