| Abstract: | Tuberculosis (TB) causes almost 2 million deaths annually, and an increasing number of patients are resistant to existing therapies. Patients who have TB require lengthy chemotherapy, possibly because of poor penetration of antibiotics into granulomas where the bacilli reside. Granulomas are morphologically similar to solid cancerous tumors in that they contain hypoxic microenvironments and can be highly fibrotic. Here, we show that TB-infected rabbits have impaired small molecule distribution into these disease sites due to a functionally abnormal vasculature, with a low-molecular-weight tracer accumulating only in peripheral regions of granulomatous lesions. Granuloma-associated vessels are morphologically and spatially heterogeneous, with poor vessel pericyte coverage in both human and experimental rabbit TB granulomas. Moreover, we found enhanced VEGF expression in both species. In tumors, antiangiogenic, specifically anti-VEGF, treatments can “normalize” their vasculature, reducing hypoxia and creating a window of opportunity for concurrent chemotherapy; thus, we investigated vessel normalization in rabbit TB granulomas. Treatment of TB-infected rabbits with the anti-VEGF antibody bevacizumab significantly decreased the total number of vessels while normalizing those vessels that remained. As a result, hypoxic fractions of these granulomas were reduced and small molecule tracer delivery was increased. These findings demonstrate that bevacizumab treatment promotes vascular normalization, improves small molecule delivery, and decreases hypoxia in TB granulomas, thereby providing a potential avenue to improve delivery and efficacy of current treatment regimens.As one of the most prevalent infectious diseases in the world today, Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) infects roughly one-third of the global population, resulting in 2 million deaths annually (1). Although current treatment regimens are largely successful in curing the disease (2), they require 6–8 mo of treatment with up to four agents (3), and multidrug-resistant bacterial strains have emerged and proliferated (4). Resistance to front-line therapies necessitates treatment with up to five or six second-line agents that are poorly tolerated, and treatment success is only achieved in 40–70% of patients (5). Failure to cure drug-resistant disease leads to acquisition of further resistance with a progressively poorer prognosis for these patients, thus fueling an emerging epidemic of drug-resistant disease that threatens to overwhelm fragile health care systems in developing countries (6).When infected with the tuberculosis (TB) bacilli, the body triggers an immune response that walls off the bacteria in dense cellular masses known as granulomas, or tubercular lesions (7). These abnormal tissue structures, which can vary in size within the same host, are surrounded by fibrous cuffs that serve to contain the MTB bacilli (7, 8). Recent studies have demonstrated a wide variation in the spatial distribution of drugs within TB granulomas, with very few agents able to penetrate the central regions (9). This differential ability of drugs to penetrate TB granulomas has been incorporated into modern TB drug development programs as a criterion for optimizing lead molecules and selecting efficacious combinations (10). However, the mechanisms that contribute to this differential penetration of drugs are not fully understood, and novel strategies to improve TB drug delivery and efficacy are urgently needed.Following infection with MTB, pulmonary granulomas form in humans and develop heterogeneous microenvironments, often featuring hypoxia (i.e., low levels of oxygen) and central necrosis, which are recapitulated in nonhuman primate and rabbit models of the disease (11). Large lesions appear to develop their own vasculature, presumably allowing them to continue to grow (7). However, the morphological and functional characteristics of granuloma-associated vessels are largely unknown. In solid tumors, cancer cells can form similar dense tissue masses with abnormal associated vasculature. The physiological abnormalities that characterize tumor vessels have been investigated extensively (12, 13). For example, hypoxia, a common feature in solid tumors, stimulates the overproduction of proangiogenic factors, such as VEGF. Proangiogenic factors enhance the formation of new immature, tortuous, and hyperpermeable vessels (12, 14), often with excess endothelial cells, a lack of associated pericytes (i.e., perivascular cells), and uneven basement membranes (15–17). These atypical features result in an impaired blood flow that further compromises delivery of drugs and oxygen (13). Hypoxia also causes immunosuppression, inflammation, and fibrosis, and it can also confer resistance to many drugs (18). Here, we propose that TB granulomas share many characteristics with solid tumors, namely, that they are associated with abnormal and dysfunctional vasculature that can impair the delivery of small molecules, such as oxygen and antibiotics.Because VEGF is a critical growth factor required for new blood vessel formation (16), anti-VEGF agents were originally developed to block tumor growth by inhibiting blood vessel formation (19). However, bevacizumab, a humanized monoclonal antibody developed to neutralize human VEGF, failed to improve survival benefit as a monotherapy but conferred survival benefit only in combination with chemotherapy or immunotherapy (18). A potential explanation for the success of combined therapies is that bevacizumab “normalizes” the abnormal vasculature of tumors, resulting in improved delivery of concurrently administered anticancer drugs, as well as alleviation of hypoxia (13, 15, 18, 20, 21). However, this strategy has not been tested in a TB disease model. In this study we show, for the first time to our knowledge, in a rabbit model of TB that treatment with bevacizumab normalizes granuloma vasculature, reduces hypoxia, and enhances small molecule delivery during a “window of normalization,” a transient effect observed in tumors (15, 20). Because anti-VEGF drugs have been approved for both malignant and nonmalignant diseases (18), our findings could be rapidly tested in the clinic to enhance TB treatment, shorten treatment duration, and avert the development of treatment resistance. |
