Critical incidents and invulnerability to risk: Young people's experience of serious health-related incidents and their willingness to take health risks

Previous research has established that young people tend to operate with a sense of invulnerability when it comes to risk-taking behaviour. This paper initially investigates the possibility that this might be a product of their relative lack of exposure to situations or events which involve death or serious threats to health. It then considers the thesis that exposure to such ‘serious health-related incidents’ will act as’ critical incidents' affecting the health-related behaviour of young people. Findings are based on the ESRC-funded research project Critical Incidents and Risk-Taking Behaviour Among Schoolchildren (R000 22 1802) which has investigated perceptions of risk and the consumption of alcohol and tobacco by 15-to 16-year-olds in a central region of England. The research reveals a high level of exposure to ‘serious health-related incidents’ and the findings provide some modest support for this thesis that these act as ‘critical incidents’ shaping the willingness of the young people to take risks with their health. However, the findings also indicate signficant limitations to the thesis. These limitations are discussed and it is concluded that they stem from the use of ‘expert opinion’ and ‘medical models’ of health as the bases for identifying critical incidents.