Associations of Frequency and Duration of Patient-Doctor Contact in Hemodialysis Facilities with Mortality

It is unknown whether regular patient-doctor contact (PDC) contributes to better outcomes for patients undergoing hemodialysis. Here, we analyzed the associations between frequency and duration of PDC during hemodialysis treatments with clinical outcomes among 24,498 patients from 778 facilities in the international Dialysis Outcomes and Practice Patterns Study (DOPPS). The typical facility PDC frequency, estimated by facility personnel, was high (more than once per week) for 55% of facilities, intermediate (once per week) for 24%, and low (less than once per week) for 21%. The mean ± SD estimated duration of a typical interaction between patient and physician was 7.7±5.6 minutes. PDC frequency and duration varied across DOPPS phases and countries; the proportion of facilities with high PDC frequency was 17% in the United States and 73% across the other countries. Compared with high PDC frequency, the adjusted hazard ratio (HR) for all-cause mortality was 1.06 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.96 to 1.17) for intermediate PDC frequency and 1.11 (95% CI, 1.01 to 1.23) for low PDC frequency (P=0.03 for trend). Furthermore, each 5-minutes-shorter duration of PDC was associated with a 5% higher risk for death, on average (HR, 1.05; 95% CI, 1.01 to 1.09), adjusted for PDC frequency and other covariates. Multivariable analyses also suggested modest inverse associations between both PDC frequency and duration with hospitalization but not with kidney transplantation. Taken together, these results suggest that policies supporting more frequent and longer duration of PDC may improve patient outcomes in hemodialysis.Although maintenance hemodialysis (HD) saves lives, survival of patients with ESRD remains poor and is much worse than for the general population.¹ HD facilities differ with respect to provision of important clinical practices;^2,3 among these, differences in patterns of dialysis unit staffing might influence mortality.^4,5 HD patients usually receive thrice-weekly dialysis provided by a multidisciplinary team of health care professionals (doctors, nurses, technicians, dietitians, and social workers). As part of this team, the physician’s role in improving the quality of chronic disease care is considered crucial.^6,7Many health care providers and researchers believe that more frequent and longer patient-doctor contact (PDC) in HD care may improve patient outcomes because it provides physicians with greater opportunity to monitor treatments; enhance communication and build trust with the patient; and detect, prevent, and treat new medical problems.^2,5,8 However, the actual frequency and duration of PDC for HD care have not been reported in many countries, and there is little direct evidence that more frequent and longer PDC contributes to better patient health outcomes. Previous studies from the United States showed that less frequent PDC was associated with lower patient satisfaction, lower patient adherence, lower patient achievement of clinical performance targets, and higher hospitalization, but more frequent PDC was not necessarily related to longer patient survival.^8–10 A recent study based on data from the U.S. Renal Data System (USRDS) also reported no difference in survival for PDC frequency of <4 times per month compared with 4 times per month.¹⁰ However, the study was limited to one country and was unable to evaluate differences in outcomes between 4 times per month and >4 times per month because of limitations of the billing codes and relatively low proportion of high PDC frequency in the United States.This study examined the estimated typical frequency and duration of PDC that occurs at the time of HD treatments and its associations with all-cause mortality as a primary outcome among participants in the Dialysis Outcomes and Practice Patterns Study (DOPPS), an international prospective cohort study of HD patients and facilities. PDC was studied at the facility level, reducing the opportunity for patient-level confounding by indication in this international cohort. Among such patients, a high PDC frequency (>4 times per month) is much more common outside of than in the United States. We also examined the associations of PDC frequency and duration with first hospitalization and kidney transplantation as secondary outcomes. A better understanding of the effect of PDC intensity could have implications for health policy in addition to improving health care delivery and HD patient outcomes.