A search for hepatitis C virus polymerase chain reaction-positive but seronegative subjects among blood donors with elevated alanine aminotransferase

BACKGROUND: Previous studies reported the existence of hepatitis C virus (HCV) polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-positive but seronegative sera. This is not surprising in the case of window-phase specimens, because PCR can detect HCV RNA many weeks before the appearance of antibody. To determine whether such sera can also be found in chronically infected subjects, a high-risk population of blood donors with elevated alanine aminotransferase was studied. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: Freshly frozen plasma from 301 donors with alanine aminotransferase > 100 IU per L was tested with PCR assays that were rigidly controlled for specificity and contamination, and with current and newer versions of assays for anti-HCV. Sera were classified as seropositive if positive in two screening assays and one supplemental assay or if positive in two screening assays and PCR. RESULTS: New versions of screening assays detected 100 percent of seropositive samples. A second-generation immunoblot assay detected 98 percent of seropositive sera, a second-generation recombinant immunoblot assay detected 96 percent, and an enzyme immunoassay for antibody to the envelope protein of HCV detected 98 percent. Fifty-one of 54 seropositive sera were PCR positive. None of the 247 seronegative samples was reproducibly positive on PCR. CONCLUSION: No PCR-positive but seronegative donors were found in this high-risk donor population. The possible benefit of PCR screening of blood donors can be determined only by large-scale comparative testing of donor populations and may be limited to the detection of window-phase infections.