| Abstract: | Circadian rhythms with an endogenous period close to or equal to the natural light–dark cycle are considered evolutionarily adaptive (“circadian resonance hypothesis”). Despite remarkable insight into the molecular mechanisms driving circadian cycles, this hypothesis has not been tested under natural conditions for any eukaryotic organism. We tested this hypothesis in mice bearing a short-period mutation in the enzyme casein kinase 1ε (tau mutation), which accelerates free-running circadian cycles. We compared daily activity (feeding) rhythms, survivorship, and reproduction in six replicate populations in outdoor experimental enclosures, established with wild-type, heterozygous, and homozygous mice in a Mendelian ratio. In the release cohort, survival was reduced in the homozygote mutant mice, revealing strong selection against short-period genotypes. Over the course of 14 mo, the relative frequency of the tau allele dropped from initial parity to 20%. Adult survival and recruitment of juveniles into the population contributed approximately equally to the selection for wild-type alleles. The expression of activity during daytime varied throughout the experiment and was significantly increased by the tau mutation. The strong selection against the short-period tau allele observed here contrasts with earlier studies showing absence of selection against a Period 2 (Per2) mutation, which disrupts internal clock function, but does not change period length. These findings are consistent with, and predicted by the theory that resonance of the circadian system plays an important role in individual fitness.Circadian clocks are a ubiquitous feature of life on earth, and serve to maintain synchrony of internal physiology with the external 24-h environment. Colin Pittendrigh, one of the founders of chronobiology, hypothesized that natural selection should favor circadian systems to operate in resonance with the external cycle (1, 2). A prediction from this hypothesis is that individuals exhibiting circadian rhythms with frequencies that are not in close resonance with the 24-h cycle should be selected against in nature. The hypothesis was initially supported by laboratory experiments in fly species that lived longer in a 24-h light–dark (LD) cycle than in non-24-h LD cycles (2–4). Stronger support emerged from dyadic competition experiments in batch cultures of cyanobacteria carrying single gene mutations affecting their circadian period (τ). Strains (either wild type or mutant) with a τ similar to the external LD cycle outcompeted strains with a τ different from the Zeitgeber (5, 6). Whether periods out of resonance with the external cycle entail a real fitness deficit in a natural setting has not been tested in any of these systems.The Ck1εtau (hereafter defined as the tau mutation) is a gain-of-function mutation (7) that accelerates the cellular dynamics of the circadian PERIOD protein (8, 9) and affects circadian behavior and physiology (10). It was first detected in Syrian hamsters (Mesocricetus auratus), where it causes τ to shorten with ∼2 h for each copy of the mutant allele (11). In mice, the same mutation shortens the circadian cycle to an almost identical extent (10). As a consequence of the accelerated circadian clockwork, both homozygote tau mice and hamsters are unable to entrain to 24-h LD cycles in the laboratory. Because its frequency deviates considerably from the natural 24-h cycle, the tau mutation provides an excellent model to study effects of deviant circadian periods on fitness in a natural setting. Here we report the consequences of deviant circadian rhythms in six replicate outdoor populations of mice. These populations were established with the release of mice, all born to two heterozygote parents, in identical enclosures, with ∼49% mutant tau alleles in a near Mendelian ratio in each pen. We used s.c. transponders to record each individual’s visits to feeders in each enclosure, which allowed us to quantify the rhythm of feeding activity and to keep track of each individual’s presence—and, hence, monitor lifespan, mortality, and the tau allele frequency in each population. |
