Superiority of HMPAO ictal SPECT to ECD ictal SPECT in localizing the epileptogenic zone

PURPOSE: We examined diagnostic performances of Tc-99m hexamethylpropylene amine oxime (HMPAO) and Tc-99m electron capture detection (ECD) ictal single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) to localize the epileptogenic zones in mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) and neocortical epilepsy (NE). METHODS: Epileptogenic zones were identified by invasive EEG or surgical outcome. Ictal SPECT was performed with stabilized Tc-99m HMPAO (TLE, 17; NE, 23) and with Tc-99m ECD (TLE, 7; NE, 7). Single-blind visual interpretation was used to localize the epileptogenic zones. Asymmetric index was calculated. Subtraction ictal SPECT was coregistered to a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) template. RESULTS: In TLE, the sensitivity of Tc-99m HMPAO SPECT was 82% (14 of 17) and that of Tc-99m ECD SPECT was 71% (five of seven). The asymmetric index (AI; 25 +/- 10) of Tc-99m HMPAO SPECT was larger (p = 0.05) than the AI (13 +/- 13) of Tc-99m ECD SPECT in patients with TLE. In NE, the sensitivity of Tc-99m HMPAO SPECT was 70% (16 of 23), but that of Tc-99m ECD SPECT was 29% (two of seven). The AI (15 +/- 10) of Tc-99m HMPAO SPECT was significantly larger (p = 0.02) than the AI (4.8 +/- 6) of Tc-99m ECD SPECT in patients with NE. Subtraction ictal SPECT coregistered to MRI supported the visual assessment. CONCLUSIONS: We concluded that the sensitivity of Tc-99m ECD ictal SPECT is similar to that of Tc-99m HMPAO ictal SPECT in TLE; however, ictal hyperperfusion was higher with the Tc-99m HMPAO SPECT. In patients with NE, Tc-99m HMPAO ictal SPECT also was superior to Tc-99m ECD ictal SPECT in sensitivity and degree of hyperperfusion.