Plasmid-Borne Virulence-Associated Genes Have a Conserved Organization in Virulent Strains of Avian Pathogenic Escherichia coli

Avian pathogenic Escherichia coli (APEC) is an important respiratory pathogen of poultry. Various virulence factors are responsible for determining the pathogenicity of these strains, and it is commonly believed they are encoded on large plasmids the strains carry. This study examined a series of strains, the pathogenicity of which had previously been determined by aerosol exposure, for possession of large plasmids and found all isolates carried at least one large plasmid, regardless of the level of virulence. Virulence-associated genes carried on these plasmids were also examined, and it was shown that highly virulent strains carried at least four virulence-associated genes on their largest plasmid. Two of the virulence-associated genes were shown to be chromosomally located in a strain of intermediate virulence, while no virulence-associated genes were carried by the low-virulence strain. The organization of the virulence-associated genes was shown to be highly conserved among APEC isolates of high virulence, supporting the concept of a conserved portion of the putative virulence region that contributes to the pathogenicity of APEC strains.Avian pathogenic Escherichia coli (APEC) strains cause respiratory disease and septicemia in poultry and are economically important worldwide, causing significant mortality (13). The carriage of large plasmids is considered characteristic of APEC isolates (8), and pathogenicity is thought to be determined by virulence-associated factors encoded by them (15). These factors include serum resistance, encoded by the iss gene (14), temperature-sensitive hemagglutination, encoded by tsh (10), adhesins, the production of colicin V (ColV) and the possession of iron-scavenging mechanisms, such as aerobactin production (encoded by the iucABCD operon), and the more recently identified putative iron transport system encoded by the etsABC operon (18).Another iron acquisition system found in APEC utilizes salmochelin, a catecholate siderophore. The chromosomal iroA gene cluster that encodes this system was first found in Salmonella enterica (2) and is absent from the corresponding region of the E. coli chromosome (32), although it has been found on a transmissible plasmid from a uropathogenic E. coli isolate (34). The iroA gene cluster has been found on multiple APEC virulence plasmids (9, 17, 18, 37), and deletion studies have shown that the iroA gene cluster is required for full virulence (9).A further iron transport system, designated the sitABCD system, was first identified on a pathogenicity island in Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (39), and it has been shown that sitABCD is required for full virulence of Salmonella serovar Typhimurium (16). Genomic subtraction identified the plasmid-located sitA gene from the sitABCD operon as unique to an APEC strain (32), and the sitA gene was found to be more prevalent in APEC than in commensal E. coli (18, 29, 32).The sitABCD operon occurs on APEC virulence plasmids (17, 18, 30, 37), but a sitABCD deletion mutant was still pathogenic for birds, suggesting that other iron transport systems are able to compensate for the loss of sitABCD (30).The carriage of ColV plasmids has previously been thought to be essential for virulence (3, 33, 38). However, other studies have suggested it is not the presence of the ColV gene itself but other genes that these plasmids carry that are responsible for virulence (28, 35). The well-characterized APEC virulence plasmids pAPEC-O2-ColV (18) and pAPEC-1 (9) encode ColV, while carriage of the Australian APEC virulence plasmid pVM01 does not confer production of ColV (12). Despite various ColV statuses, all three of these virulence plasmids are F-type plasmids, and hence this is potentially another way to characterize APEC virulence plasmids.SopA and SopB, which have similarity to the ParA and ParB proteins of the P1 plasmid, are thought to be essential for F-plasmid partitioning (22, 24). Detection of the genes of the sopABC locus could thus indicate the presence of a putative virulence plasmid.Strain E3 is an O-nontypeable:H28 APEC field isolate (11) that carries the 151-kb virulence plasmid pVM01 (12), which contains a virulence region with the virulence-associated genes iucA, tsh, iss, iroN, and sitA, as well as hlyF, ompT, and the etsABC operon (37). The arrangement of the virulence-associated genes around pVM01 (37) is similar to that in the plasmids pAPEC-O2-ColV from APEC strain O2 (18), pAPEC-O1-ColBM from APEC strain O1 (17), and pAPEC-1 from APEC strain χ7122 (23). Identifying a specific region that is conserved in highly virulent APEC strains will facilitate diagnosis of colibacillosis by differentiation of pathogenic strains from commensal E. coli and will also enable surveillance for pathogenic isolates in the environment of poultry.This study examined six E. coli strains, some of which were isolated from diseased birds and some of which were recovered from healthy birds (11, 36). The pathogenicity of these strains has been determined using aerosol exposure (11, 36), making this the largest known collection of APEC strains fulfilling Koch''s postulates. The series of strains includes the highly virulent strains E3, E30, and E956 and the less-virulent strains E133, E1043, and E1292. The presence of the virulence-associated genes iucA, tsh, and iss in these strains has previously been elucidated by PCR amplification (36). However, while previous studies have found many of these virulence factors to be encoded by APEC strains associated with disease (29) and have suggested that they are encoded on virulence plasmids (18), they have not conclusively determined whether they are encoded on virulence plasmids or are chromosomally encoded. Similarly, although previous studies suggest that these virulence-associated genes are consistently present in isolates from diseased birds (1, 6, 18, 21, 26, 29), no study has yet determined if these genes are consistently associated with each other.The aim of this study was to examine a series of strains of known pathogenicities for the possession of large plasmids and to determine if known virulence-associated genes from the putative virulence region were carried on them. The second objective was to investigate any association between the virulence-associated genes.