Reappraisal of optimal hemoglobin standards for female blood donors in Canada

BACKGROUND: A hemoglobin (Hb) standard of 115 g per L on the copper sulfate test has been in use by the Canadian Red Cross Society Blood Services for female blood donor predonation screening since 1989. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: To determine if this lowered Hb standard results in increased iron deficiency in repeat blood donors, a study was conducted to evaluate the performance of the copper sulfate test and predonation capillary and venous Hb assays in a population of female blood donors most at risk of developing iron deficiency. RESULTS: Of the 174 donors who were of childbearing age, who were not taking iron supplements, and who had made at least three blood donations per year, 45 (25.9%) were iron deficient, and 64 (36.8%) had reduced iron stores; only 65 (37.3%) had normal iron stores. This study showed that capillary blood is more likely to have a higher Hb concentration (3.2 +/− 7.8 g/L) than venous blood samples, which could affect the performance of predonation screening assays that are based on capillary blood samples at a given discriminating value. With an Hb standard of 115 g per L, both the copper sulfate and capillary Hb assays were not sensitive enough to screen for iron deficiency (sensitivity, 27% and 33%; specificity, 96% and 93%, respectively) and were comparable only to the performance of a venous Hb assay with a cutoff value of 110 g per L (sensitivity, 27%; specificity, 99%). In contrast, an Hb standard of 125 g per L in the copper sulfate test could achieve a more optimal sensitivity of 79 percent and specificity of 78 percent. CONCLUSION: This study supports the use of a higher Hb cutoff value of 125 g per L for female blood donors in the predonation fingerstick copper sulfate test.