Telomerase activity in malignant and benign renal tumors

OBJECTIVES: An important characteristic of malignant cells is their unlimited replicative potential, their immortality. In conferring this immortality, the enzyme telomerase is believed to play a crucial role. The detection of telomerase activity provides new knowledge regarding the biologic growth behavior of tumors and offers new diagnostic and therapeutic tools. METHODS: In the present study the sensitive TRAP assay (telomeric repeat amplification protocol) was used to examine 44 malignant renal tumors and 8 benign tumors of the kidney and 52 specimens of normal renal tissue for telomerase activity. RESULTS: Telomerase activity was detected in 63% of tissue samples obtained from histologically confirmed renal cell carcinomas. In cases of renal cell carcinoma restricted to the kidney, telomerase activity was detected in 58%. In cases in which tumor growth has progressed beyond the limits of the organ, telomerase activity was found in 69%. This stage dependence, however, did not reach statistical significance. No correlation to tumor grading was observed. Telomerase activity was found less frequent in chromophobe renal cell carcinomas. Neither the 8 benign renal tumors (4 oncocytomas and 4 angiomyolipomas) nor the specimens of normal kidney showed any evidence of telomerase activity. CONCLUSIONS: The proportion of remarkable slow-growing renal cell carcinomas showing telomerase activity is less than in other malignancies and may correlate with biologic growth behavior. Possible explanations include the presence of an alternative pathway, called ALT (alternative lengthening of telomeres) and an association with the loss or presence of the telomerase suppressor on the short arm of chromosome 3. Prolonged follow-up will be of special interest to determine whether lack of telomerase activity predicts favorable outcome.