Squamous papillary neoplasia of the adult upper aerodigestive tract

Selected papillary squamous tumors of the upper aerodigestive tract (UADT) mucosa in adult patients do not have well-defined histologic criteria and the clinical behavior is poorly understood. To better characterize this spectrum of neoplasms, UADT papillary neoplasms were evaluated by routine histology, determination of cellular DNA content using Feulgen-stained tissue sections, and the typing of human papillomavirus (HPV) by in situ hybridization. Solitary papillomas were studied in two patients; there was no recurrence in either case, both had normal DNA content, and one was typed as HPV-6 while the other was typed as HPV-11. Seven adult patients with recurrent papillomatosis and at least one biopsy with dysplasia/atypia were identified (mean age at diagnosis, 13.3 years; mean age at last contact, 42.7 years). Six of seven patients had abnormal DNA cellular content in foci of epithelial atypia. In all biopsies evaluated, the papillomas of the seven patients were consistently typed as either HPV-6 or HPV-11. Six patients with malignant papillary neoplasms also had abnormal DNA cellular content, but none revealed evidence of HPV type 6, 11, 16, or 18 by in situ hybridization of tissue sections. In many of the recurrent papillomas, the degree of epithelial atypia encountered was pronounced and was commonly misdiagnosed as carcinoma in situ or papillary carcinoma. The aneuploid DNA content of these foci of atypia reflected the abnormal cellular appearance and partially explained the overdiagnosis of malignancy. However, none of the seven patients were treated for malignant disease and none progressed to invasive carcinoma, with an average follow-up period of almost 30 years. We conclude that histologic and cytologic atypia in HPV-containing papillomatosis may be appreciable. The aneuploid DNA content may represent premalignant conditions and the patient may be at an increased risk for the subsequent development of squamous cancer. However, none of the seven patients with recurrent papillomatosis developed any evidence of malignancy. In addition, none of the patients with papillary carcinomas had previous recurrent papillomatosis.