| Abstract: | Existing drugs are slow to eradicate Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) in patients and have failed to control tuberculosis globally. One reason may be that host conditions impair Mtb’s replication, reducing its sensitivity to most antiinfectives. We devised a high-throughput screen for compounds that kill Mtb when its replication has been halted by reactive nitrogen intermediates (RNIs), acid, hypoxia, and a fatty acid carbon source. At concentrations routinely achieved in human blood, oxyphenbutazone (OPB), an inexpensive anti-inflammatory drug, was selectively mycobactericidal to nonreplicating (NR) Mtb. Its cidal activity depended on mild acid and was augmented by RNIs and fatty acid. Acid and RNIs fostered OPB’s 4-hydroxylation. The resultant 4-butyl-4-hydroxy-1-(4-hydroxyphenyl)-2-phenylpyrazolidine-3,5-dione (4-OH-OPB) killed both replicating and NR Mtb, including Mtb resistant to standard drugs. 4-OH-OPB depleted flavins and formed covalent adducts with N-acetyl-cysteine and mycothiol. 4-OH-OPB killed Mtb synergistically with oxidants and several antituberculosis drugs. Thus, conditions that block Mtb’s replication modify OPB and enhance its cidal action. Modified OPB kills both replicating and NR Mtb and sensitizes both to host-derived and medicinal antimycobacterial agents.Some bacterial infections can be cured with a single dose of an antibiotic, and most others can be cured with administration of one drug over several days or weeks. In contrast, routine treatment of drug-sensitive tuberculosis (TB) takes 2 mo of therapy with four drugs and an additional 4 mo with two drugs to reduce the 2-y relapse rate below 5%. The difficulty of completing prolonged treatment is a major reason for emergence of drug resistance. When the infecting strain is resistant to isoniazid and rifampin, the two drugs recommended for all 6 mo of treatment, cure often requires 2 y of daily administration of toxic, expensive, second-line agents that are often unavailable at the point of care. When the causative strain is additionally resistant to a quinolone and an aminoglycoside, the resultant “extensively drug-resistant” TB was fatal to 80% of patients in a leading center (1), although complex multidrug regimens have achieved higher cure rates in populations not previously exposed to the additional drugs (2). In addition to sharing air with someone with TB, leading risk factors for contracting the disease are malnutrition, HIV infection, diabetes, and exposure to smoke from cigarettes or cooking fires (3). These epidemiological challenges exacerbate problems of inadequate diagnostic technology and limited access to drug susceptibility testing and to drugs. Control of the pandemic is not in sight (3).It is widely hypothesized that treatment of TB is protracted because nonreplicating (NR) subpopulations of bacilli are phenotypically tolerant to drugs that were selected for activity against replicating (R) Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) (4). Mtb can occupy diverse microenvironments in the host. Evidence from auxotrophs, analyses of gene expression, and direct and indirect biochemical measurements in vivo or ex vivo in experimental animals and people suggest that such environments expose Mtb to acid, hypoxia, reactive nitrogen intermediates (RNIs), oxidative stress, carbohydrate deficiency, and metal starvation or intoxication, and require Mtb to metabolize fatty acids or cholesterol (5–17). In vitro, many of the same conditions can make Mtb relatively refractory to killing by the standard agents, except for pyrazinamide, which is only effective at a low pH.Thus, there is a need for a high-throughput screen (HTS) for compounds that kill Mtb when the Mtb has been rendered NR by a combination of physiologically relevant host-imposed conditions. We were encouraged to devise such a screen by recent discoveries of a class of compounds that kill Mtb only when it is NR (18), an antibiotic in clinical use for other infections that kills NR Mtb better than R Mtb (19), and a compound that kills NR and R Mtb equally well (20). Unfortunately, only one of those compounds is an approved drug, and even if it were of proven utility in TB, its price would preclude its use by most of those who need it. We decided to screen other existing drugs that are not regarded as antiinfectives for those that kill NR Mtb. Here, we report finding such a drug in an HTS that combined four host-imposed conditions, some of which converted the drug into a form active on both R and NR Mtb. |
