Immunohistochemical and Ultrastructural Analysis of Bronchopulmonary Neuroendocrine Neoplasms. II. Well-Differentiated Neuroendocrine Carcinomas

We have attempted to characterize a group of bronchopulmonary neoplasms that share certain structural features with true carcinoids but appear distinctly more pleomorphic and behave far more aggressively. In reviewing our files from 1973 to 1982, 11 such neoplasms were identified; the original diagnoses were “atypical bronchial carcinoid” (3 cases), “malignant carcinoid” (1 case), “bronchial carcinoid” (3 cases), “peripheral carcinoid” (2 cases), and “peripheral oat cell carcinoma” (2 cases).

Of the 11 neoplasms, 5 were central and 6 were peripherally located. At presentation, 7 patients had lymph node rnetastases and 1 had a distant metastasis. No patient had a conventionally defined hormonal syndrome; however, 2 patients had a history of episodic flushing, one of which was associated with diarrhea.

All cases were studied by light microscopy and light microscopic immunohistochemistry for NSE (neuron-specific enolase), serotonin, and broad-spectrum neuropeptides. Five cases were studied by electron microscopy. By light microscopy, the tumors were composed of solid clusters of polygonal to fusiform cells in an evident organoid arrangement. Foci of glandular and/or squamous differentiation were seen in 7 cases. Pleomorphism was moderate and mitoses were readily found. Focal necrosis was seen. By immunohistochemistry, 10 cases expressed NSE immu-noreactivity. All cases demonstrated hormonal immu-noreactivity; in 9 cases, immunoreactivity for more than one hormone was observed. The hormones most frequently expressed were serotonin, bombesin, gastrin, leu-enkephalin, and ACTH.

By electron microscopy, all cases studied contained heterogeneous populations of neurosecretory granules; the latter, however, were not abundant and tended to aggregate either in the basal pole of the cells or, more frequently, in interlacing “dendritelike” cytoplasmic processes. Aggregates of intermediate filaments were frequently seen. Basal lamina deposition was seen but gaps and larger areas of discontinuity were frequent.

We believe that these neoplasms constitute a distinct pathologic entity for which the term “well-differentiated neuroendocrine carcinomay” has been proposed. Clinically, these tumors merit special attention since they are demonstrably more aggressive than true carcinoids but are distinctly less malignant than the intermediate or small cell variants of neuroendocrine carcinoma.