Evaluation of Four Commercial Immunoglobulin G (IgG)- and IgM-Specific Enzyme Immunoassays for Diagnosis of Mycoplasma pneumoniae Infections

The four following commercially available enzyme immunoassays (EIAs) were assessed and compared for their performance in detecting Mycoplasma pneumoniae immunoglobulin G (IgG)- and IgM-specific antibodies Platelia EIA, ImmunoWELL M. pneumoniae ELISA IgG and IgM, ETI-MP-IgG and IgM EIAs and Biotest anti-M. pneumoniae IgG and IgM ELISA (referred to herein as EIA-Platelia, EIA-BMD, EIA-Sorin, and EIA-Biotest). Three groups of patients were investigated: 39 patients (27 children and 12 adults) with respiratory infections who tested positive by PCR for M. pneumoniae in respiratory specimens (group I; 52 serum samples), 61 healthy children and adults (group II; 61 serum samples), and 20 patients with rheumatoid factor or antinuclear antibodies, or who tested positive for antiviral IgM (group III; 20 serum samples). In group III, the IgM specificity for EIA-Platelia, EIA-BMD, EIA-Biotest, and EIA-Sorin was 100, 90, 65, and 25%, respectively. In the children from group I, the four EIAs had similar IgM sensitivities (89 to 92%); the sensitivity for IgG was greater with EIA-BMD and EIA-Biotest than with EIA-Platelia and EIA-Sorin (66 and 78% versus 55 and 52%, respectively). In adult patients from group I, 9 to 10 serum samples were positive for IgG with a concordant sensitivity of 75 to 83% between the four EIAs but a striking difference in IgM sensitivity: 16% by EIA-Platelia and EIA-BMD, 50% by EIA-Biotest, and 58% by EIA-Sorin. Discrepant and unexpected results were observed in IgM detection from control healthy patients using EIA-Sorin and EIA-Biotest, confirming the lack of specificity of these two EIAs and making them inaccurate for routine diagnosis. A good concordance of IgG seroprevalence in healthy adults was found between the four EIAs (66 to 70%), though this concordance was lower with EIA-Platelia (43%). In healthy children, EIA-BMD and EIA-Biotest gave a higher IgG seroprevalence than EIA-Sorin and EIA-Platelia (45% each for the former compared to 17 and 20%, respectively, for the latter). These results confirm that the IgM EIA serology test is a valuable tool for the early diagnosis of M. pneumoniae infections in children, as long as the EIA used is specific. In adults, the difficult interpretation of EIAs suggests that paired sera, combined with PCR detection on respiratory tract specimens collected on admission of patient, should be required for accurate diagnosis.