Variability of the steady-state visually evoked potential: Interindividual variance and intraindividual reproducibility of spatial frequency tuning

At low contrast levels there is good agreement between the psychophysical contrast sensitivity function and the tuning curve of the visually evoked potential (i.e., VEP amplitude vs spatial frequency). At high contrast, however, some researchers have found bimodal VEP tuning curves whereas others have not. We studied the VEP in 22 subjects in a short-term cross-sectional study and in 13 subjects in a longitudinal study over 8 sessions covering 28 days. Grating stimuli with 60% contrast were square-wave modulated in time (7.8 reversals/s) and space (0.06–16 cycles/degree). We found large interindividual variance in the shape of the tuning curves; about half of the subjects showed a unimodal shape, while the other half showed a bimodal one (with a notch between 1 and 2 cycles/degree). These features turned out to be stable in the longitudinal study, where variability could mainly be ascribed to a multiplicative influence common to all spatial frequencies. The marked interindividual differences in the shape of the tuning curve, which seem to be intraindividually stable, may explain previous discrepancies. It is not yet clear why the notch exists in about half of our subjects.