Self-paced exercise performance in the heat with neck cooling,menthol application,and abdominal cooling

Objectives

To investigate whether the exercise performance benefits with neck cooling in the heat are attributable to neck-specific cooling, general body cooling, a cooler site-specific thermal perception or a combination of the above.

Design

Counter-balanced crossover design.

Methods

Twelve healthy participants cycled in the heat (34 °C, 30% relative humidity), at a power output (PO) self-selected to maintain a fixed rating of perceived exertion (RPE) of 16. Each participant underwent four experimental trials: no cooling (CON), neck cooling (NEC), abdominal cooling (ABD), or neck cooling with menthol (MEN). Participants cycled for 90 min or until their workload reduced by <70% of their initial PO. Changes in PO, rectal temperature (T_re), mean skin temperature (T_sk), whole-body thermal sensation (TS_wb) and thermal sensation of the neck (TS_neck) were recorded throughout.

Results

The mean reduction in PO throughout exercise was similar (p = 0.431) for CON (175 ± 10 W), NEC (176 ±12 W), ABD (172 ± 13 W) and MEN (174 ± 12 W). The ΔT_re at the end of exercise was similar (p = 0.874) for CON (0.83 ± 0.5 °C), NEC (0.85 ± 0.5 °C), ABD (0.82 ± 0.5 °C) and MEN (0.81 ± 0.5 °C). TS_wb was cooler (p < 0.013) in MEN (125 ± 8 mm) compared to CON (146 ± 19 mm), NEC (135 ± 11 mm) and ABD (141 ± 16 mm).

Conclusions

No differences in exercise performance or thermal strain were observed in any of the cooling trials compared to the CON trial, despite significantly cooler TS_wb values in the MEN and NEC trials compared to the CON trial. These findings differ from previous observations and highlight that the benefit of neck cooling may be situation dependent.