Clinical practice guidelines and the cost of care. A growing alliance

Healthcare policy, medical practice, and cost of care are no longer considered distinct entities. Each is an integral factor in determining not only what, but how, patient care will be delivered. Clinical practice guidelines are the lynchpin that connects them. This paper addresses the various components of the clinical practice guideline--cost alliance. OBJECTIVE: To examine the bidirectional influence of choice of care on costs and of cost of care on decision making. METHODS: The literature was used to identify cost-related factors that influence development of guidelines and change in physician practice behavior. In a MEDLINE search with modifiers to the keywords "clinical practice guidelines," particular attention was paid to identifying surveys of practitioners. An analysis, prompted by a recently published guideline, of treating penetrating intraperitoneal colon injuries by different surgical approaches (primary repair versus diverting colostomy) exemplified how implementation of a guideline can affect the cost of care. Inpatient cost estimates, adjusted for medical inflation and cost-to-charge ratios and reported in 1999 U.S. dollars, were developed using data from 1996 and 1997 discharge databases from California and Massachusetts. RESULTS: The results showed that a substantial savings in hospital costs was achieved when a primary repair surgical technique, as advocated by the guideline, was used. The effect of cost influences on the development of clinical practice guidelines was established by demonstrating the cyclical effect between usual and customary practices, guideline implementation, changing practice patterns, and the economic considerations influencing the process. CONCLUSIONS: A growing, albeit uneasy, alliance between costs and clinical practice guidelines is evident.