Renal transplantation from non-heart-beating donors: a single-center 10-year experience

BACKGROUND: Reluctance to accept non-heart-beating donors (NHBD) as a source of kidneys, is due to medical, ethical, and logistical reasons. Evidence suggest that the short-term graft survival is similar to that of kidneys obtained from heart-beating donors (HBD). However, few studies, with long-term follow-up are available. We conducted a single-center study of kidneys obtained from NHBD, in a 14-year period. METHODS: We studied 100 patients transplanted with kidneys between 1989 and 2004, using NHBD, supported by heart compression and mechanical ventilation (n = 24), intravascular in situ cooling (n = 59), or cardiorespiratory resuscitation plus manual abdominal counterpulsation without cooling (n = 17), the last technique being used from 1998. The median follow-up was 51 +/- 51 months (range, 1 to 170). The outcomes of these procedures were compared to those of 1025 transplantations of kidneys from HBD performed during the same period. RESULTS: The characteristics of the recipients did not differ significantly between the two groups. Kidneys from NHBD showed a significantly higher rate of delayed graft function (DGF; 84% vs 26%; (P < .001), furthermore, the primary nonfunction (PNF) incidence was significantly higher with NHBD vs HBD (16% vs 10%; P < .001). The incidence of acute rejection episodes (ARE) within 3 months and at 1 year did not differ between the groups of donors; however, more NHBD kidneys were lost from ARE. The short-term (3-month and 1 year) and long-term (5 and 10 years) renal function, determined by the serum creatinine levels, and patient and graft survival were not different for kidneys obtained from NHBD. CONCLUSIONS: The incidences of PNF and DGF were significantly higher with NHBD, which produced poorer renal function at the time of hospital discharge. One-, 5-, and 10-year graft survivals and renal function did not differ between NHBD and HBD grafts. In our series, PNF was the main barrier to the use of NHBD.