Cingulo-opercular control network and disused motor circuits joined in standby mode

Whole-brain resting-state functional MRI (rs-fMRI) during 2 wk of upper-limb casting revealed that disused motor regions became more strongly connected to the cingulo-opercular network (CON), an executive control network that includes regions of the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC) and insula. Disuse-driven increases in functional connectivity (FC) were specific to the CON and somatomotor networks and did not involve any other networks, such as the salience, frontoparietal, or default mode networks. Censoring and modeling analyses showed that FC increases during casting were mediated by large, spontaneous activity pulses that appeared in the disused motor regions and CON control regions. During limb constraint, disused motor circuits appear to enter a standby mode characterized by spontaneous activity pulses and strengthened connectivity to CON executive control regions.

Disuse is a powerful paradigm for inducing plasticity that has uncovered key organizing principles of the human brain (1–4). Monocular deprivation—prolonged covering of one eye—revealed that multiple afferent inputs can compete for representational territory in the primary visual cortex (1). Similar competition between afferents also shapes the somatomotor system. Manipulations such as peripheral nerve deafferentation, whisker trimming, and limb constraint all drive plasticity in the primary somatosensory and motor cortex (2–4). Most plasticity studies to date have used focal techniques, such as microelectrode recordings, to study local changes in brain function. As a result, little is known about how behavior and experience shape the brain-wide functional networks that support complex cognitive operations (5).The brain is composed of networks of regions that cooperate to perform specific cognitive functions (5–8). These functional networks show synchronized spontaneous activity while the brain is at rest, a phenomenon known as resting-state functional connectivity (FC) (9–11). FC can be measured noninvasively in humans using resting-state functional MRI (rs-fMRI) and has been used to parse the brain into canonical functional networks (12, 13), including visual, auditory, and somatomotor networks (14, 15); ventral and dorsal attention networks (8, 16); a default mode network with roles in internally directed cognition and episodic memory (7, 11); a salience network thought to assess the homeostatic relevance of external stimuli (17); a frontoparietal control network supporting error processing and moment-to-moment adjustments in behavior (18–20); and a cingulo-opercular control network (CON), which maintains executive control during goal-directed behavior (18, 19, 21). Each functional network likely carries out a variety of additional functions.A more recent advance in human neuroscience has been the recognition of individual variability in network organization (22–25). Most early rs-fMRI studies examined central tendencies in network organization using group-averaged FC measurements (10, 12, 13). Recent work has demonstrated that functional networks can be identified in an individual-specific manner if sufficient rs-fMRI data are acquired, an approach termed precision functional mapping (PFM) (22, 23, 26–30). PFM respects the unique functional anatomy of each person and avoids averaging together functionally distinct brain regions across individuals.We recently demonstrated that PFM can be used to follow the time course of disuse-driven plasticity in the human brain (31). Three adult participants (Nico, Ashley, and Omar) were scanned at the same time of day for 42 to 64 consecutive days (30 min of rs-fMRI per day) before, during, and after 2 wk of dominant upper-extremity casting (Fig. 1 A and B). Casting caused persistent disuse of the dominant upper extremity during daily behaviors and led to a marked loss of strength and fine motor skill in all participants. During casting, the upper-extremity regions of the left primary somatomotor cortex (L-SM1_ue) and right cerebellum (R-Cblm_ue) functionally disconnected from the remainder of the somatomotor network. Disused motor circuits also exhibited large, spontaneous pulses of activity (Fig. 1C). Disuse pulses did not occur prior to casting, started to occur frequently within 1 to 2 d of casting, and quickly waned after cast removal.Open in a separate windowFig. 1.Experimental design and spontaneous activity pulses. (A) Three participants (Nico, Ashley, and Omar) wore casts covering the entire dominant upper extremity for 2 wk. (B) Participants were scanned every day for 42 to 64 consecutive days before, during, and after casting. All scans included 30 min of resting-state functional MRI. (C) During the Cast period, disused somatomotor circuits exhibited large pulses of spontaneous activity. (C, Left) Whole-brain ANOVA showing which brain regions contained disuse-driven pulses. (C, Right) Time courses of all pulses recorded from the disused primary somatomotor cortex.Somatomotor circuits do not function in isolation. Action selection and motor control are thought to be governed by complex interactions between the somatomotor network and control networks, including the CON (18). Prior studies of disuse-driven plasticity, including our own, have focused solely on somatomotor circuits. Here, we leveraged the whole-brain coverage of rs-fMRI and the statistical power of PFM to examine disuse-driven plasticity throughout the human brain.