| Abstract: | One hundred four patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the upper aerodigestive tract and with histologically positive surgical margins were evaluated for this historically controlled study to determine the efficacy of postoperative radiation therapy. Positive margins were defined as the presence of one or more of the following: carcinoma in situ, tumor within 0.5 cm from the surgical margins, microscopic disease, or dysplasia. Patients received either surgery alone (44 cases) or surgery plus postoperative radiation therapy (60 cases) and were followed for a minimum of 2 years. Treatment strategies, stage by stage, were similar for all patients. Surgery varied from simple excision in T1 to composite resection and/or laryngopharyngectomy with radical neck dissection in advanced cases. Radiation therapy was given postoperatively with doses ranging from 4,500 to 7,500 cGy. The overall 2-year survival rate with no evidence of disease (NED) was consistently higher in the surgery plus radiation therapy group. Furthermore, when the subgroup of patients who had dysplasia at the surgical margins was excluded from the analysis, the 2-year NED survival rate difference became statistically significant (p = 0.05). This outcome favored combined therapy (36 of 58 patients) over surgery alone (13 of 32 patients). This favorable result was obtained despite the high percentage of T3-T4 stages (79 vs. 21%) and clinically positive lymph nodes (83 vs. 17%) in patients who had received postoperative radiation therapy. The significance of dysplasia at the surgical margins and the impact of radiation therapy on the tumor and nodal control in this group of patients needs further clarification. |
