Comparison of insulin hypoglycemia and short metyrapone tests in patients with pituitary disease

Summary In a retrospective study on 59 patients (2 hypothalamic, 44 pituitary, 13 no confirmed disease) 69 pairs of insulin hypoglycemia tests (IHT) and short metyrapone tests (SMT) were evaluated. Cortisol and 11-desoxy-cortisol rsp. were compared as the endpoints. In 6 cases, the IHT was a technical failure because of insufficient hypoglycemia. In 25% of 63 pairs of tests, both tests were normal, (Group I), in 30% both abnormal (Gr. II). In 21%, IHT was normal, SMT abnormal (Gr. III) and in 24% IHT was abnormal and SMT normal (Gr. IV). The 2 patients with hypothalamic disease were in Group IV with completely normal SMT and severely pathological IHT. Other discrepancies could not be attributed to special pituitary disorders. In 9 patients of Group III and in 8 patients of Group IV (n=17), the IHT alone was repeated 6–48 months after the original pair of tests which had been performed in most cases early after pituitary surgery. In 12 cases, the repeat IHT followed the trend of the SMT of the original test pair. In 5 cases, the IHT was unchanged. 14 of 19 patients of Group II, but only 5 of 28 patients of Group III and IV required permanent substitution with hydrocortisone.Conclusions. The SMT may be normal in patients wilth clearcut hypothalamic dysfunction of the CRF-ACTH axis. In pituitary disease, IHT and SMT seem to be equivalent tests of dysfunction. After pituitary surgery, the SMT may be a better prognostic test of ACTH recovery than the IHT. Permanent substitution therapy with hydrocortisone is usually required when both tests are abnormal, but rarely necessary if only one of the tests is abnormal.Abbreviations IHT Insulin hypoglycemia test - SMT Short metyrapone testPresented in part to the 90th Congress of the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Innere Medizin, Wiesbaden, 29.4.–3.5.1984