Comparison of functional outcomes of Duhamel and transanal endorectal coloanal anastomosis for Hirschsprung's disease

Purpose

The aim of this study was to determine the morbidity and medium-term functional outcome of the Duhamel operation and laparotomy and transanal endorectal coloanal anastomosis (TECA) for Hirschsprung’s disease (HSCR).

Methods

The study populations were 34 consecutive children who underwent the Duhamel operation (or Lester Martin modification) and 37 who had the TECA. Demographic details were obtained by case note review, and functional outcome was determined by a combination of outpatient interview, questionnaire, and telephone enquiry.

Results

There was no difference between the groups with respect to age, gender, and length of aganglionic segment. Seventy percent presented as neonates (Duhamel, 24 of 34; TECA, 26 of 37). A single-stage primary pull-through was performed in 17 of 37 children in the TECA group, and in 1 of 34 from the Duhamel group. There was a single perioperative death in the Duhamel group and an unrelated, late death in the TECA group. Postoperative enterocolitis was seen in 13 of 37 TECA children and in a single child from the Duhamel group. A stricture of the pull-through segment was seen in 7 of 37 children after TECA and required temporary diversion in 2 of 9. Late division of a rectal spur was required in 6 of 33 Duhamel children. Requirement for late myectomy was the same in both groups (Duhamel 3 of 33, TECA 4 of 37). Complications requiring stoma formation occurred in 5 of 37 after TECA and 2 of 33 after the Duhamel operation. Two children from the TECA group and 1 from the Duhamel group remain diverted. One child from each group required a re-pull-through procedure. Two patients were lost to follow-up in the TECA group, leaving 34 children in this group and 33 in the Duhamel group in whom functional outcome could be assessed. Functional outcome was similar in the 2 groups.

Conclusions

TECA and Duhamel procedures have similar medium-term functional outcomes. TECA has a high incidence of postoperative enterocolitis and transient stricture formation but is suitable for single-stage neonatal treatment of HSCR.