A single topical dose of erythropoietin applied on a collagen carrier enhances calvarial bone healing in pigs

Background and purpose

The osteogenic potency of erythropoietin (EPO) has been documented. However, its efficacy in a large-animal model has not yet been investigated; nor has a clinically safe dosage. The purpose of this study was to overcome such limitations of previous studies and thereby pave the way for possible clinical application. Our hypothesis was that EPO increases calvarial bone healing compared to a saline control in the same subject.

Methods

We used a porcine calvarial defect model. In each of 18 pigs, 6 cylindrical defects (diameter: 1 cm; height: 1 cm) were drilled, allowing 3 pairwise comparisons. Treatment consisted of either 900 IU/mL EPO or an equal volume of saline in combination with either autograft, a collagen carrier, or a polycaprolactone (PCL) scaffold. After an observation time of 5 weeks, the primary outcome (bone volume fraction (BV/TV)) was assessed with high-resolution quantitative computed tomography. Secondary outcome measures were histomorphometry and blood samples.

Results

The median BV/TV ratio of the EPO-treated collagen group was 1.06 (CI: 1.02–1.11) relative to the saline-treated collagen group. Histomorphometry showed a similar median effect size, but it did not reach statistical significance. Autograft treatment had excellent healing potential and was able to completely regenerate the bone defect independently of EPO treatment. Bony ingrowth into the PCL scaffold was sparse, both with and without EPO. Neither a substantial systemic effect nor adverse events were observed. The number of blood vessels was similar in EPO-treated defects and saline-treated defects.

Interpretation

Topical administration of EPO on a collagen carrier moderately increased bone healing. The dosing regime was safe, and could have possible application in the clinical setting. However, in order to increase the clinical relevance, a more potent but still clinically safe dose should be investigated.Erythropoietin (EPO) is a hematopoietic growth factor that stimulates the formation of red blood cells. In recent years, the non-hematopoietic effects of EPO have been investigated. Of interest for skeletal tissue engineering, the pleiotropic capabilities of EPO include osteogenic and angiogenic potencies (Rölfing et al. 2012). Subcutaneous injections of 250 IU/kg EPO were found to enhance bone formation 6 weeks after operation in a spinal fusion model in rabbits (Rölfing et al. 2012). The validity of the methodology of this study was confirmed in a recently published meta-analysis (Riordan et al. 2013, Rölfing and Bünger 2013). Other independent research groups have reported increased bone formation in mice and rats after daily treatment with 200–6,000 IU/kg EPO (Bozlar et al. 2006, Holstein et al. 2007, 2011, Shiozawa et al. 2010, Garcia et al. 2011, Kim et al. 2012). Furthermore, vascularization of 3-dimensional scaffolds for bone tissue regeneration remains a challenge. The described pleiotropic functions of EPO may overcome this limitation of skeletal tissue engineering in the future. EPO could possibly facilitate angiogenesis directed into the core of the scaffold, thereby facilitating bony ingrowth. Moreover, EPO promotes a direct and indirect osteogenic stimulation of mesenchymal stromal cells (Shiozawa et al. 2010, Rölfing et al. 2013).Translation of these promising in vitro and in vivo data into clinical trials requires a physiological dosage of EPO in order to avoid its known complications, such as thromboembolism (Ehrenreich et al. 2009, Shiozawa et al. 2010, Kim et al. 2012, Rölfing et al. 2012). Notably, we observed an extremely high hematocrit level after 250 IU/kg EPO for 20 days in a rabbit model (Rölfing et al. 2012). In other in vivo studies, repetitive EPO injections ranging from 500 to 6,000 IU/kg were administered. These treatment regimes have a systemic effect, and thus hold the risk of adverse events. Testing of the efficacy of a clinically safe dose of EPO is therefore necessary before clinical trials can be considered. Aiming for clinical progress and feasibility, the present study was carried out with a view to evaluating the efficacy of a single, low-dose EPO to stimulate bone healing in a large-animal study. The dose of EPO was chosen based on the following considerations. The translation of the minimally effective dose in cell studies into large-animal models is difficult (Rölfing et al. 2013). The rather low dosage of 2,700 IU/animal, equivalent to 18.5 ± 2.0 IU/kg, was chosen in order to minimize the systemic effect of EPO due to safety concerns and in order to minimize the potential effect on the within-subject controls. In anemic patients, 20–240 IU/kg are injected subcutaneously or intravenously 3 times a week. The hypothesis was that 900 IU site-specifically applied EPO would increase bony ingrowth compared to a saline-treated control in a porcine calvarial defect model.