Separation of on-target efficacy from adverse effects through rational design of a bitopic adenosine receptor agonist

The concepts of allosteric modulation and biased agonism are revolutionizing modern approaches to drug discovery, particularly in the field of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs). Both phenomena exploit topographically distinct binding sites to promote unique GPCR conformations that can lead to different patterns of cellular responsiveness. The adenosine A₁ GPCR (A₁AR) is a major therapeutic target for cardioprotection, but current agents acting on the receptor are clinically limited for this indication because of on-target bradycardia as a serious adverse effect. In the current study, we have rationally designed a novel A₁AR ligand (VCP746)—a hybrid molecule comprising adenosine linked to a positive allosteric modulator—specifically to engender biased signaling at the A₁AR. We validate that the interaction of VCP746 with the A₁AR is consistent with a bitopic mode of receptor engagement (i.e., concomitant association with orthosteric and allosteric sites) and that the compound displays biased agonism relative to prototypical A₁AR ligands. Importantly, we also show that the unique pharmacology of VCP746 is (patho)physiologically relevant, because the compound protects against ischemic insult in native A₁AR-expressing cardiomyoblasts and cardiomyocytes but does not affect rat atrial heart rate. Thus, this study provides proof of concept that bitopic ligands can be designed as biased agonists to promote on-target efficacy without on-target side effects.G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are the largest family of cell surface proteins and tractable drug targets (1, 2). Unfortunately, there remains a high attrition rate associated with traditional GPCR-based drug discovery that, in part, reflects an emphasis on the endogenous agonist binding (orthosteric) site as the predominant means of achieving selective GPCR drug targeting (3). Over the last decade, substantial breakthroughs have occurred in the exploitation of topographically distinct GPCR allosteric sites as a means for attaining greater selectivity, especially in those instances where there is high sequence similarity in the orthosteric site across GPCR subtypes (4–6). However, there are increasing examples where both the therapeutic effect and adverse effects are mediated by the same GPCR target (7). In these situations, the desired selectivity needs to be attained at the level of the intracellular signaling pathways linked to a given receptor subtype.GPCRs are highly dynamic proteins, fluctuating between different conformations; these conformations can be linked to different cellular outcomes (8). Thus, chemically distinct ligands, interacting with either orthosteric or allosteric sites, have the potential to stabilize different interaction networks within a GPCR to promote a subset of signaling pathways linked to the receptor at the expense of others. This phenomenon has been termed biased agonism (7, 9, 10). The overall promise of biased agonism is the ability to design GPCR ligands that selectively engage therapeutically relevant signaling pathways while sparing pathways that contribute to undesirable side effects mediated by the same target.The adenosine receptor (AR) family is an important class of physiologically and therapeutically relevant GPCRs that can benefit substantially from more selective drug targeting. Although all four AR subtypes are expressed in the mammalian heart (11, 12), the well-known protective effects of adenosine in this tissue are predominantly mediated by the adenosine A₁ receptor (A₁AR) subtype, especially under conditions of ischemia and reperfusion injury (13–17). Unfortunately, the transition of A₁AR agonists into the clinic has been severely hindered because of high doses causing on-target bradycardia, atrioventricular block, and hypotension (13, 18). As a consequence, clinical trials of AR agonists have had limited success because of the suboptimal dose of agonist that can be used (19–22). It is possible that this problem may be overcome through the exploitation of biased agonism at the A₁AR.Although no study has identified biased orthosteric A₁AR ligands, we recently showed that the 2-amino-3-benzoylthiophene allosteric modulator (VCP171) could promote biased signaling in the activity of the prototypical orthosteric agonist, R(-)N6-(2-phenylisopropyl) adenosine (R-PIA) (23). Thus, we hypothesized that the rational design of a bitopic ligand (i.e., a class of hybrid molecule containing both orthosteric and allosteric pharmacophores) (24–26) may be able to achieve high efficacy and biased agonism at the A₁AR in a single molecule. Herein, we report proof of concept that it is possible to use this approach as a means to dissociate on-target efficacy from on-target side effects.