Murine sarcoma viruses: the helper-independence reported for a Moloney variant is unconfirmed; distinct strains differ in the size of their RNAs.

A variant of Moloney murine sarcoma virus (Mo-MSV) reported to behave like a nondefective sarcoma virus was subjected to biological and biochemical analyses to determine whether its alleged helper-independence could be confirmed. When plated at low multiplicity the virus was shown to readily generate (four out of six) transformed clones which failed to produce virus unless superinfected with helper leukemia virus. The RNA of the parental virus stock was compared electrophoretically to that from clones which produced virus after the initial infection (producer clones) or after superinfection with Mo-murine leukemia virus (MLV) (nonproducer clones). All clones contained a MSV-specific 30 S RNA species. In addition, virus from one producer clone also contained 38 S MLV RNA at a high relative concentration, indicating that the original Mo-MSV stock must have contained such an RNA species. However, the original virus stock as well as virus from another producer clone contained 38 S MLV RNA at a low, uncertain relative concentration. A hypothesis consistent with these and previous data suggests that the Mo-MSV variant investigated here is defective and contains helper leukemia virus at a low concentration. This explains (i) the ready generation of nonproducer clones by infection at low multiplicity, (ii) the difficulty in detecting helper leukemia virus 38 S RNA in the original virus stock, and (iii) the low complexity (approximately 1.9 × 10⁶ daltons) of the MSV-specific 30 S RNA. These results are compatible with the properties reported for a defective MSV genome, but incompatible with those of a nondefective MSV genome. The MSV-specific RNA components of different clonal isolates of Mo-MSV differed from each other in size, ranging between 2.1 and 1.6 × 10⁶. The Harvey sarcoma virus-specific RNA was 1.9 × 10⁶, that of Kirsten sarcoma virus was 2.5 × 10⁶, and the spleen focus forming component of Friend virus was 2.0 × 10⁶. The sarcoma- or transformation-specific RNA components of all transforming viruses tested here were smaller than the 38 S RNA of helper leukemia viruses of 3.1 × 10⁶.