Antigen affinity and antigen dose exert distinct influences on CD4 T-cell differentiation

Cumulative T-cell receptor signal strength and ensuing T-cell responses are affected by both antigen affinity and antigen dose. Here we examined the distinct contributions of these parameters to CD4 T-cell differentiation during infection. We found that high antigen affinity positively correlates with T helper (Th)1 differentiation at both high and low doses of antigen. In contrast, follicular helper T cell (T_FH) effectors are generated after priming with high, intermediate, and low affinity ligand. Unexpectedly, memory T cells generated after priming with very low affinity antigen remain impaired in their ability to generate secondary Th1 effectors, despite being recalled with high affinity antigen. These data challenge the view that only strongly stimulated CD4 T cells are capable of differentiating into the T_FH and memory T-cell compartments and reveal that differential strength of stimulation during primary T-cell activation imprints unique and long lasting T-cell differentiation programs.Following infection, T-cell receptor (TCR) interactions with foreign peptide/MHC (pMHC) drive the rapid clonal expansion and differentiation of T cells into distinct effector subsets specialized against different classes of microbes. An early bifurcation in CD4 T-cell responses results in the generation of T helper (Th)1 effectors, which regulate innate cell microbicidal function and follicular helper T (T_FH) cells, which migrate to B-cell follicles to regulate germinal center (GC) responses and antimicrobial antibody production (1). After pathogen is cleared, T cells undergo a contraction phase during which the majority of effectors die by apoptosis, leaving behind a population of long-lived memory cells to provide protection upon subsequent reinfection. The decision to differentiate into Th1 and T_FH lineages appears to occur very early in the immune response (2, 3). Initial T-cell priming by dendritic cells (DCs) is sufficient to induce fate-committed Th1 and T_FH cells as early as 3 d after infection, whereas maintenance and further expansion of the T_FH compartment depends on T-cell interactions with B cells (2). Similarly, memory T-cell differentiation occurs very early after infection and is critically dependent on B-cell interactions for optimal priming (4, 5). Importantly, CD4 T-cell differentiation is coupled to division, and unlike CD8 T-cell differentiation, requires constant antigen recognition (6, 7).Although the strength of TCR–pMHC interactions has been shown to directly modulate T-cell expansion and clonal dominance within the Th cell compartment (8, 9), how this influences CD4 T-cell fate is not well understood. Cumulative TCR signaling can be influenced by both antigen affinity and antigen dose (10). In terms of proliferation, higher antigen dose can compensate for lower antigen affinity to some extent, but several reports have shown independent effects on T-cell responses both in vitro and in vivo (10–12). These data indicate that antigen affinity and antigen dose may promote qualitatively distinct TCR signals. Recently, modulation of the overall TCR signal by varying either TCR affinity or antigen dose was shown to influence the pattern of effector T-cell differentiation, with higher affinity ligands or higher antigen dose promoting T_FH generation (13–15). However, another study examining high and low avidity CD4 T-cell responses during viral infection found significant differences in Th1 but not T_FH generation (16). Sustained TCR–pMHC interactions have also been shown to promote memory T-cell differentiation, which is associated with increased TCR avidity (17, 18). These studies, however, have focused on the development of the Th1 memory compartment, which is phenotypically and functionally distinct from the T_FH memory compartment (19, 20). Thus, although strong TCR signals resulting from high antigen affinity or high antigen dose can clearly affect the extent and quality of T-cell differentiation, whether or not T cells can discriminate these signals, and how this contributes to T-cell differentiation during infection, has not been determined.To address this question, we infected mice with varying concentrations of Listeria expressing either high or low affinity antigens for the TCR. By normalizing the degree of proliferation induced by high and low affinity antigens we were able to discern distinct influences of antigen affinity and antigen dose on Th cell differentiation. We observed a strong positive correlation between antigen affinity and Th1 differentiation that occurs early and is dose independent. Importantly, high antigen dose does not compensate for the low efficiency of Th1 differentiation induced by low affinity antigen. In contrast, early T_FH effector generation was observed after priming with high, intermediate, and low affinity antigen, but was not maintained at later time points under conditions of low antigen dose. In addition, we found that T cells activated by either high or low affinity antigen are equally capable of memory T-cell differentiation. Surprisingly, memory T cells generated by either low antigen affinity or low antigen dose maintained their biased effector lineages following recall activation with high affinity antigen. These data indicate that differential strength of stimulation during primary T-cell activation can imprint unique and long lasting T-cell differentiation programs.