Analog specific aberrancies in antifolate inhibition of L1210 cell dihydrofolate reductase

During studies with L1210 cells and a variety of folate analogs, large discrepancies were revealed between data on membrane transport, on inhibition of dihydrofolate reductase in cell-free extracts, and on inhibition of growth in culture for 10-oxa-, 10-benzyl- and 10-phenethyl-aminopterin, and for 3-deaza, 10-methyl-aminopterin. While aminopterin, 10-methyl (methotrexate)-, 10-ethyl- and 10-propyl-aminopterin were tight binding inhibitors (K_i: 2–3 × 10^?12M) of dihydrofolate reductase in cell-free extracts from L1210 cells, the other four analogs were only weak competitive inhibitors (K_i = 3–300 × 10^?8M). Similar differences among analogs were observed for inhibition of dihydrofolate reductase in cell-free extracts from Sarcoma 180 and Ehrlich cells, but not for this enzyme in microbial cell-free extracts. There were only small differences in the transport of all of the analogs by L1210 cells. Inhibition of L1210 cell growth in culture by 10-oxa-, 10-benzyl- and 10-phenethyl-aminopterin and by 3-deaza, 10-methyl-aminopterin, in contrast to the other analogs, was several orders of magnitude greater than that predicted from the data on dihydrofolate reductase inhibition. The extent of binding of 10-oxa-, 10-benzyl- and 10-phenethyl-aminopterin, and of 3-deaza and 10-methyl-aminopterin to dihydrofolate reductase in intact L1210 cells, in contradistinction to that seen for the cell-free enzyme preparations, approached that observed for methotrexate; these estimates of drug-enzyme interaction in situ were more predictive of the extent of inhibition by these analogs of L1210 cell growth in culture.