A Syndemic of Psychosocial Health Disparities and Associations With Risk for Attempting Suicide Among Young Sexual Minority Men

Objectives. We examined a syndemic of psychosocial health issues among young men who have sex with men (MSM), with men and women (MSMW), and with women (MSW). We examined hypothesized drivers of syndemic production and effects on suicide attempts.Methods. Using a pooled data set of 2005 and 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Surveys from 11 jurisdictions, we used structural equation modeling to model a latent syndemic factor of depression symptoms, substance use, risky sex, and intimate partner violence. Multigroup models examined relations between victimization and bullying experiences, syndemic health issues, and serious suicide attempts.Results. We found experiences of victimization to increase syndemic burden among all male youths, especially MSMW and MSM compared with MSW (variance explained = 44%, 38%, and 10%, respectively). The syndemic factor was shown to increase the odds of reporting a serious suicide attempt, particularly for MSM (odds ratio OR] = 5.75; 95% confidence interval CI] = 1.36, 24.39; P < .001) and MSMW (OR = 5.08; 95% CI = 2.14, 12.28; P < .001) compared with MSW (OR = 3.47; 95% CI = 2.50, 4.83; P < .001).Conclusions. Interventions addressing multiple psychosocial health outcomes should be developed and tested to better meet the needs of young MSM and MSMW.Substantial evidence has been accumulating over the past several decades to suggest that men who have sex with men (MSM) experience substantial disparities in many facets of health.1 An important characteristic of these disparities is that they tend to arise early in the life course. For example, meta-analyses have shown that by adolescence and young adulthood MSM experience significantly higher rates of depression,2 substance use,3 HIV sexual risk behaviors,4 and suicidality2 than do their heterosexual peers. Little research has been conducted on the health of young men who have sex with men and women (MSMW). The few empirical studies separating adolescent MSM from adolescent MSMW have shown that adolescent MSMW report significantly higher rates of substance use, including tobacco use, than do their heterosexual3 and MSM5–9 counterparts. Additionally, MSMW have been found to be more likely to report HIV sexual risk behaviors than are their heterosexual peers.9One theoretical explanation for these disparities is syndemics.10–12 Syndemic theory posits that as individuals are confronted with adversity across the life course, particularly in the forms of social marginalization and victimization, they develop psychosocial health problems such as low self-image, depression, and substance use.13 These conditions tend to co-occur, which has a snowballing effect on overall health. In fact, several studies have demonstrated that as the number of psychosocial conditions within an individual increases, so does their risk of major negative health outcomes.10–12,14 It follows from this argument that young MSM, who experience far greater levels of adversity than do heterosexual youths,15–18 would also experience greater rates of syndemics and higher rates of the resulting negative health outcomes.We examined syndemic production in a population-based sample of young men and its association with serious suicide attempts. By looking at syndemics in a large enough sample that could be broken into MSM, MSMW, and men who have sex with women (MSW), we sought to determine whether syndemics are a general human phenomenon or whether they exist and are associated with negative health outcomes only for certain socially marginalized populations.10,11,19 We also examined the structure of the syndemic construct by testing for measurement invariance using multigroup confirmatory factor analysis (CFA),20 which, essentially, asks whether the meaning of the syndemic construct is the same across groups. Next we examined the relation between experienced adversity and syndemic production to see whether this association exists for all groups of young men, and if so, to what degree. Finally, we tested the relationship between syndemics and a serious adverse health outcome—making a life-threatening suicide attempt—and whether the negative effects were the same across groups.