Diagnosis of schizophrenia by computer and clinicians: A pilot study

Investigations show significant disagreement among mental health professionals in diagnosing schizophrenia.^1–11 Recently, computer-based systems have been used in attempts to improve diagnostic consistency. Spitzer and Endicott, among others, have devised a computer program using the Mental Status Examination Report (MSER) as input data.^12–19 The MSER is a systematic, relatively objective inventory of observed behaviors used to obtain a mental status. The MSER was used at the Hillside Division during 1973 and 1974. It was filled out 1 week after admission by therapists who were specially trained for this task. It was noted that a nonschizophrenic computer diagnosis was given to a number of patients diagnosed schizophrenic by clinicians, but the reverse rarely occurred. Was this due to the computer program, the MSER, clinicians, or other factors? These questions have heightened relevance in light of the imminence of Professional Standards Review Organization (PSRO).²⁰ Hospitals may be required to establish definitive operational diagnostic criteria and correlated treatments in order to maintain accreditation and be reimbursed by third-party payers. This study investigated these diagnostic discrepancies in order to ascertain what specific criteria could be used in making a schizophrenic diagnosis in hospitalized patients. Secondarily, the study sought to shed further light on whether such a computer system could be useful as an adjunctive diagnostic modality to pinpoint difficult cases.