Completely laparoscopic versus open gastrectomy for early and advanced gastric cancer: a matched cohort study

Introduction

The application of laparoscopic gastric surgery has rapidly increased for the treatment of early gastric cancer. However, laparoscopic gastrectomy for advanced tumor remains controversial, particularly in terms of oncologic outcomes. This study was designed to compare 3-year survival of laparoscopic versus open curative gastrectomy in early and advanced gastric cancer.

Methods

This was a retrospective matched cohort study. We included patients between 2003 and 2010 with an R0 resection. A totally laparoscopic technique was used and D2 lymph node dissection was practiced routinely. We performed an intracorporeal hand-sewn esophagojejunostomy in all laparoscopic total gastrectomy cases. We matched all laparoscopic cases 1:1 with open cases according to TNM AJCC seventh edition. We used Mann–Whitney or t test and Chi-square test to compare both groups. Kaplan–Meier analysis with log-rank test was performed to compare survival.

Results

We included 31 open and 31 laparoscopic cases (mean age 63?±?14?years; 66% males). Both groups were identical in type of gastrectomy (71% total and 29% subtotal). There were no statistical difference between laparoscopic and open groups in age, sex, N category, tumor location and size, histological differentiation, and T category (48% T1, 13% T2, 16% T3, and 23% T4 in both groups), with 48% early and 52% advanced tumors. The median number of resected lymph nodes was similar: 35 (23–53) for laparoscopic and 39 (23–45) for open cases (P?=?0.81). The median follow-up was 50?months. The overall 3-year survival was 82% for laparoscopic surgery and 87% for the open surgery group (P?=?0.56). There were no difference in 3-year survival for the laparoscopic versus the open surgery groups for advanced tumors (74 vs. 75%, P?=?0.88), N+?tumors (73 vs. 73%, P?=?0.99) and for the different AJCC stages (stage 1: 94 vs. 100%, stage 2: 89 vs. 82%, and stage 3: 50 vs. 50%, P?=?0.32, 0.83, and 0.98 respectively).

Conclusions

In this preliminary report, with 52% of advanced tumor, the 3-year overall and stage-by-stage survival was comparable for laparoscopic and open curative gastrectomy.