Contrast-enhanced MRI of the subdeltoid,subacromial bursa in painful and painless rotator cuff tears

Objective

Although shoulder pain is often associated with rotator cuff tears, many tears are asymptomatic and are not the cause of the patient''s pain. This may explain the persistence of symptoms in some patients despite technically successful rotator cuff repair. It has been proposed that rotator cuff tears cause pain through subdeltoid/subacromial bursal inflammation. The aim of this study was to determine whether bursal inflammation seen on MRI is associated with pain in patients with rotator cuff tears of the shoulder.

Methods

The shoulders of 255 patients were screened with ultrasound. 33 full-thickness rotator cuff tears (18 with shoulder pain and 15 without pain) were identified and subsequently studied using contrast-enhanced MRI of the shoulder. Enhancement of the subacromial bursa was scored independently by two musculoskeletal radiologists. Logistic regression was used to determine whether bursal enhancement was independently associated with pain.

Results

There was a significant association between pain and age, with greater likelihood of pain in younger patients. Bursal enhancement was common in both painful and painless tears. No statistically significant link between pain and bursal enhancement was seen, even after accounting for age.

Conclusion

Although enhancement of the subdeltoid/subacromial bursa was common, no evidence was found to support the hypothesis that bursal enhancement is associated with pain in rotator cuff tears. It is therefore unlikely to determine reliably which patients would benefit from rotator cuff repair.

Advances in knowledge

Bursal enhancement and thickening does not reliably correlate with symptoms or presence of rotator cuff tear.Rotator cuff tears are a common cause of pain in the shoulder. Surgical repair is an effective treatment, but a significant proportion of patients (5–12.5%) fail to achieve a satisfactory outcome [1-4]. Long-term outcome of surgery correlates poorly with the integrity of the cuff repair [5-7] and persistence of pain is a major factor [1]. In some cases, this may be because the shoulder pain is not due to rotator cuff damage at all [8]. Other painful shoulder pathologies are common, particularly in the elderly, including glenohumeral and acromioclavicular arthritis [9], and bone marrow oedema [10]. Asymptomatic rotator cuff tears are common, with increasing incidence with age and a reported prevalence of up to 80% in subjects aged over 80 years [11]. A significant proportion of these are full-thickness tears with one study reporting full-thickness tears in 28% of people over the age of 60 [12]. Rotator cuff tears may remain asymptomatic despite their large size [13] and, although the size of tears often increases, symptoms may develop or resolve with conservative treatment [14-16]. As yet there is no clear consensus regarding the indications for rotator cuff surgery [17,18]. A technique to determine whether a known rotator cuff tear is responsible for an individual patient''s pain would therefore be of great clinical value in developing patient management plans. While MRI has been shown to be accurate for detecting rotator cuff tears [19,20], there is no convincing evidence to date that it can be used to determine whether a full-thickness tear is symptomatic [12,21].The mechanism by which rotator cuff tears cause pain is poorly understood. Tears are associated with histological inflammation of the subdeltoid/subacromial bursa and this has recently been proposed as a cause of pain [22]. Synovial inflammation in the bursa in symptomatic rotator cuff tears could potentially be detected by the associated enhancement in the inflamed bursa seen on MRI after the administration of intravenous contrast agent, in the same way that synovial volume in joints in inflammatory arthritis has been shown to correlate with histological measures of inflammation [23]. The aim of this study was to use contrast-enhanced MRI to assess subacromial bursitis in patients with painful and painless rotator cuff tears in order to test the hypothesis that synovial enhancement at the subacromial bursa is greater in patients with shoulder pain.