Differences between membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis types I and III in clinical presentation, glomerular morphology, and complement perturbation

Data for 26 patients with membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis, type I (MPGN I) and 22 with membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis, type III (MPGN III), as distinguished by glomerular ultrastructure, were analyzed to determine differences in presentation, complement perturbation, and glomerular morphology by light microscopy. MPGN III was detected with greater frequency by the chance discovery of hematuria and proteinuria in the otherwise healthy individual (MPGN III, 63%; MPGN I, 30%; P = .01) and never, in the absence of renal failure, presented with systemic symptoms such as ease of fatigue, weight loss, and pallor, as may patients with MPGN I. The more frequent detection of MPGN III by chance is evidence that its onset is insidious and that for long periods it produces no symptoms or signs. Glomerular proliferation is also less than in MPGN I. Further, in MPGN III, the complement perturbation and glomerular immunofluorescence give no evidence of classical pathway activation, for which there is abundant evidence in MPGN I. Even with severe hypocomplementemia in MPGN III, C3 nephritic factor, another cause of hypocomplementemia, is rarely detectable and then in very low concentration. The cause of the complement perturbation in MPGN III has so far escaped identification. Although these observations give evidence that MPGN III is distinct from MPGN I, there is compelling evidence from other studies that a predisposition to both types is inherited and that similar genetic factors are operative in the two types. Because their genetic basis appears to be the same, it must be concluded that despite their differences, types I and III are variants of the same disease.