Changed gait pattern in patients with total knee arthroplasty but minimal influence of tibial insert design

Introduction Previous radiostereometric studies have revealed abnormal anterior-posterior translation of the femur in patients operated with AMK (DePuy, Johnson and Johnson, Leeds, UK) total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Based on these observations, we hypothesized that patients with TKA have an abnormal gait pattern, and that there are differences in kinematics depending on the design of the tibial joint area.

Method We used a gait analysis system to evaluate the influence of joint area design on the kinematics of the hip and knee during level walking. 39 TKA patients (42 knees) and 18 healthy age-matched controls were studied. Patients with 5° varus/valgus alignment or less were randomized to receive either a relatively flat or a concave tibial insert with retention of the posterior cruciate ligament. Patients who had more than 5° varus-valgus alignment and/or extension defect of 10° or more were randomized to receive the concave or a posterior-stabilized tibial component with resection of the posterior cruciate ligament.

Results Patients with TKA tended to have less hip and knee extension and decreased knee and hip extension moment than controls. They also tended to walk more slowly. TKA altered the gait pattern, but choice of implant design had little influence.

Interpretation In patients with a similar degree of degenerative joint disease and within the limits of the constraints offered by the prostheses under study, the choice of joint area constraint has little influence on the gait pattern.