高渗盐水联合羟乙基淀粉治疗严重脓毒症的研究

目的 评价7.5%高渗盐水(HS)联合6%羟乙基淀粉(HES)130/0.4对严重脓毒症患者早期液体复苏的效果.方法 采用前瞻性随机对照研究.选取江汉大学附属医院重症监护病房(ICU)135例严重脓毒症患者,入ICU时随机分成3组,每组45例.HS+HES组输注7.5%HS后输注6%HES 130/0.4 500 ml,再输注平衡液HES组输注6%HES 130/0.4后输注平衡液;平衡液组(RL组)仅输注平衡液.比较3组患者入ICU后6 h、24 h平均动脉压(MAP)、氧合指数(PaO2/FiO2)、动脉血乳酸、乳酸清除率、急性生理学与慢性健康状况评分系统Ⅱ(APACHE Ⅱ)评分、输液量、尿量以及多器官功能障碍综合征(MODS)发生率和住院病死率.结果 入ICU后6 h,HS+HES组MAP[mm Hg(1 mm Hg=0.133 kPa):68.7±3.0]、PaO2/FiO2(mm Hg:262.2±17.4)、乳酸清除率[(21±4)%]较HES组[MAP:63.8±3.5,PaO2/FiO2:252.0±21.2,乳酸清除率:(11±2)%]和RL组[MAP:62.6±3.6,PaO2/FiO2:248.4±17.0,乳酸清除率:(9±1)%]显著增高(均P＜0.01),动脉血乳酸(mmol/L:3.5±0.7)较HES组(4.1±0.7)和RL组(4.0±0.7)显著下降(均P＜0.01);APACHE Ⅱ评分(分:13.2±1.9)与HES组(14.0±1.6)无明显差异,但显著低于RL组(15.2±1.7,P＜0.01).入ICU后24 h,HS+HES组PaO2/FiO2(mm Hg:303.3±17.3)显著高于HES组(282.9±21.1)和RL组(268.9±15.2,均P＜0.01),但3组间MAP、动脉血乳酸、乳酸清除率和APACHE Ⅱ评分均无差异.人ICU后6 h、24 h,HS+HES组输液量(ml,6 h:1 877.8±215.2,24 h:5 475.6±208.8)显著低于HES组(6 h:2 505.6±276.2,24 h:6 383.3±287.4)和RL组(6 h:3 496.7±325.5,24 h:7 439.6±229.6);尿量(ml,6 h:294.2±36.9,24 h:2 793.8±37.1)显著高于HES组(6 h:248.9±25.3,24 h:2 248.9±25.3)和RL组(6 h:178.9±14.8,24 h:2 000.4±147.0,均P＜0.01).HS+HES组MODS发生率(6.7%)远低于RL组(28.9%,P＜0.05),与HES组(17.8%)无差异(P＞0.05);3组间病死率无显著差异(HS+HES组2.2%,HES组4.4%,RL组8.9%,均P＞0.05).结论 7.5%HS联合6%HES 130/0.4能提高严重脓毒症患者早期液体复苏的效果,降低MODS发生率.

Abstract：

Objective To evaluate the effect of 7. 5% hypertonic saline(HS)and 6% hydroxyethyl starch (HES)130/0.4 on early fluid resuscitation for severe sepsis. Methods Prospective randomized control trial was carried out in intensive care unit(ICU)of the Affiliated Hospital of Jianghan University. One hundred and thirty-five patients with severe sepsis were randomly divided into three groups, each group consisted of 45 patients. Patients in HS+HES group received lactated Ringer solution following 4 ml/kg of 7. 5%HS and 6%HES 130/0. 4 500 ml, those in HES group received lactated Ringer solution following 6%HES 130/0.4500 ml, and those in the lactated Ringer group(RL group)received lactated Ringer solution only. Mean arterial pressure(MAP), oxygenation index(PaO2/FiO2), arterial lactate(Lac), lactate clearance rate,acute physiology and chronic health evaluation Ⅱ(APACHE Ⅱ)score, fluid infusion volume, urine output as well as incidence of multiple organ dysfunction syndrome(MODS), and mortality were compared among three groups at 6 hours and 24 hours after ICU admission. Results At 6 hours after ICU admission, MAP [mm Hg(1 mm Hg=0. 133 kPa): 68. 7±3. 0], PaO2/FiO2(mm Hg: 262.2±17.4), lactate clearance rate [(21±4)%]in HS+HES group were significantly higher than those in HES group[MAP: 63. 8±3.5,PaO2/FiO2: 252.0 ± 21.2, lactate clearance rate:(11± 2)%]and RL group[MAP: 62.6 ± 3. 6, PaO2/FiO2 :248. 4±17.0, lactate clearance rate:(9± 1)%, all P＜0. 01]. Arterial Lac in HS+HES group(mmol/L:3. 5±0. 7)was significantly lower than that in HES group(4. 1±0. 7)and RL group(4. 0±0. 7, both P＜0. 01). There was no significant difference in APACHE Ⅱ score between HS+HES group(13. 2±1.9)and HES group(14.0±1.6), and the APACHE Ⅱ score in HS+HES group was significantly lower than that in RL group(15. 2 ± 1.7, P＜ 0. 01). At 24 hours after ICU admission, PaO2/FiO2(mm Hg: 303.3 ± 17.3)was significantly higher in HS+HES group than that in HES group(282.9 ± 21.1)and RL group(268. 9 ±15.2,both P＜ 0.01). There was no significant difference in MAP, arterial Lac, lactate clearance rate and APACHE Ⅱ score among three groups. At 6 hours and 24 hours after ICU admission, fluid infusion volume in HS+HES group(ml, 6 hours: 1 877. 8±215. 2, 24 hours: 5 475.6±208.8)was markedly less than that in HES group(6 hours: 2 505.6±276.2, 24 hours: 6 383. 3±287.4)and RL group(6 hours: 3 496. 7±325.5, 24 hours: 7 439.6±229.6), yet urine output in HS+HES group(ml, 6 hours: 294.2±36.9,24 hours: 2 793.8 ±37.1)was significantly higher than that in HES group(6 hours: 248.9 ± 25. 3,24 hours: 2 248. 9±25. 3)and RL group(6 hours: 178. 9±14.8, 24 hours: 2 000. 4±147.0, all P＜0. 01).The incidence of MODS in HS+HES group(6.7%)was statistically lower than that in RL group(28. 9%,P＜0. 05), while no obvious difference was found between HS+HES group and HES group(17.8%, P＞0. 05). There was no significant difference in mortality among three groups(HS+HES group: 2.2%, HES group: 4.4%, RL group: 8.9%, all P＞0. 05). Conclusion 7.5%HS and 6%HES 130/0. 4 could improve the effect of early fluid resuscitation on severe sepsis, and it could lower the incidence of MODS.

The study of hypertonic saline and hydroxyethyl starch treating severe sepsis

Objective To evaluate the effect of 7. 5% hypertonic saline(HS)and 6% hydroxyethyl starch (HES)130/0.4 on early fluid resuscitation for severe sepsis. Methods Prospective randomized control trial was carried out in intensive care unit(ICU)of the Affiliated Hospital of Jianghan University. One hundred and thirty-five patients with severe sepsis were randomly divided into three groups, each group consisted of 45 patients. Patients in HS+HES group received lactated Ringer solution following 4 ml/kg of 7. 5%HS and 6%HES 130/0. 4 500 ml, those in HES group received lactated Ringer solution following 6%HES 130/0.4500 ml, and those in the lactated Ringer group(RL group)received lactated Ringer solution only. Mean arterial pressure(MAP), oxygenation index(PaO2/FiO2), arterial lactate(Lac), lactate clearance rate,acute physiology and chronic health evaluation Ⅱ(APACHE Ⅱ)score, fluid infusion volume, urine output as well as incidence of multiple organ dysfunction syndrome(MODS), and mortality were compared among three groups at 6 hours and 24 hours after ICU admission. Results At 6 hours after ICU admission, MAP [mm Hg(1 mm Hg=0. 133 kPa): 68. 7±3. 0], PaO2/FiO2(mm Hg: 262.2±17.4), lactate clearance rate [(21±4)%]in HS+HES group were significantly higher than those in HES group[MAP: 63. 8±3.5,PaO2/FiO2: 252.0 ± 21.2, lactate clearance rate:(11± 2)%]and RL group[MAP: 62.6 ± 3. 6, PaO2/FiO2 :248. 4±17.0, lactate clearance rate:(9± 1)%, all P＜0. 01]. Arterial Lac in HS+HES group(mmol/L:3. 5±0. 7)was significantly lower than that in HES group(4. 1±0. 7)and RL group(4. 0±0. 7, both P＜0. 01). There was no significant difference in APACHE Ⅱ score between HS+HES group(13. 2±1.9)and HES group(14.0±1.6), and the APACHE Ⅱ score in HS+HES group was significantly lower than that in RL group(15. 2 ± 1.7, P＜ 0. 01). At 24 hours after ICU admission, PaO2/FiO2(mm Hg: 303.3 ± 17.3)was significantly higher in HS+HES group than that in HES group(282.9 ± 21.1)and RL group(268. 9 ±15.2,both P＜ 0.01). There was no significant difference in MAP, arterial Lac, lactate clearance rate and APACHE Ⅱ score among three groups. At 6 hours and 24 hours after ICU admission, fluid infusion volume in HS+HES group(ml, 6 hours: 1 877. 8±215. 2, 24 hours: 5 475.6±208.8)was markedly less than that in HES group(6 hours: 2 505.6±276.2, 24 hours: 6 383. 3±287.4)and RL group(6 hours: 3 496. 7±325.5, 24 hours: 7 439.6±229.6), yet urine output in HS+HES group(ml, 6 hours: 294.2±36.9,24 hours: 2 793.8 ±37.1)was significantly higher than that in HES group(6 hours: 248.9 ± 25. 3,24 hours: 2 248. 9±25. 3)and RL group(6 hours: 178. 9±14.8, 24 hours: 2 000. 4±147.0, all P＜0. 01).The incidence of MODS in HS+HES group(6.7%)was statistically lower than that in RL group(28. 9%,P＜0. 05), while no obvious difference was found between HS+HES group and HES group(17.8%, P＞0. 05). There was no significant difference in mortality among three groups(HS+HES group: 2.2%, HES group: 4.4%, RL group: 8.9%, all P＞0. 05). Conclusion 7.5%HS and 6%HES 130/0. 4 could improve the effect of early fluid resuscitation on severe sepsis, and it could lower the incidence of MODS.