Death due to anaesthesia at Groote Schuur Hospital, Cape Town--1956-1987. Part II. Causes and changes in aetiological pattern of anaesthetic-contributory death

A general analysis of the clinical failures that were responsible for deaths attributable to anaesthesia over a 30-year period, 1956-1987, is presented. Four particular general failures in clinical management were responsible for 80% of anaesthetic-contributory deaths (ACD). These were in descending order of frequency: (i) failures in airway management, of which the majority were associated with the complications of endotracheal intubation (27% of ACD); (ii) failures in pulmonary ventilation management (20% of ACD); (iii) failures in blood volume control (19% of ACD); and (iv) failures in arrhythmia control (17% of ACD). Computation of these groups of causes by the decade reveals a distinct and progressive change in the aetiological pattern of these deaths with time. While the incidence of ACD over the period decreased 6-fold from 0.43 to 0.07/1,000 anaesthetics, that proportion due to failures in airway management, in general, and complications of intubation, in particular, has progressively increased. This has been accompanied by a reciprocal decrease in deaths due to circulatory factors. It is postulated that this change arises from the fact that the physical skills, manual dexterity and clinical judgement demanded by the former have not changed with time, whereas the latter depend on intellectual responses to information derived from ever-improving vital function monitoring.