Concept of lymphoid versus myeloid dendritic cell lineages revisited: both CD8alpha(-) and CD8alpha(+) dendritic cells are generated from CD4(low) lymphoid-committed precursors

Two dendritic cell (DC) subsets have been identified in the murine system on the basis of their differential CD8alpha expression. CD8alpha(+) DCs and CD8alpha(-) DCs are considered as lymphoid- and myeloid-derived, respectively, because CD8alpha(+) but not CD8alpha(-) splenic DCs were generated from lymphoid CD4(low) precursors, devoid of myeloid reconstitution potential. Although CD8alpha(-) DCs were first described as negative for CD4, our results demonstrate that approximately 70% of them are CD4(+). Besides CD4(-) CD8alpha(-) and CD4(+) CD8alpha(-) DCs displayed a similar phenotype and T-cell stimulatory potential in mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR), although among CD8alpha(-) DCs, the CD4(+) subset appears to have a higher endocytic capacity. Finally, experiments of DC reconstitution after irradiation in which, in contrast to previous studies, donor-type DCs were analyzed without depleting CD4(+) cells, revealed that both CD8alpha(+) DCs and CD8alpha(-) DCs were generated after transfer of CD4(low) precursors. These data suggest that both CD8alpha(+) and CD8alpha(-) DCs derive from a common precursor and, hence, do not support the concept of the CD8alpha(+) lymphoid-derived and CD8alpha(-) myeloid-derived DC lineages. However, because this hypothesis has to be confirmed at the clonal level, it remains possible that CD8alpha(-) DCs arise from a myeloid precursor within the CD4(low) precursor population or, alternatively, that both CD8alpha(+) and CD8alpha(-) DCs derive from an independent nonlymphoid, nonmyeloid DC precursor. In conclusion, although we favor the hypothesis that both CD8alpha(+) and CD8alpha(-) DCs derive from a lymphoid-committed precursor, a precise study of the differentiation process of CD8alpha(+) and CD8alpha(-) DCs is required to define conclusively their origin.