Variable capacity of 13 hepatitis B virus surface antigen assays for the detection of HBsAg mutants in blood samples

BackgroundNatural variation and mutations in the envelope protein (S) of hepatitis B virus can translate into HBsAg variants no longer detectable by conventional HBsAg assays.ObjectivesThe aim of the study was to assess the performance of 13 commercial assays currently used for screening and clinical analysis of HBsAg variants.Study designThe limit of detection (LOD) for each assay was established using two reference standards (WHO HBsAg 00/588 and the SFTS French reference). Sensitivity was evaluated using different panels. Panel 1 included 25 recombinant HBs variants at three concentrations, panels 2 and 4 included 8 recombinant HBsAg variants and 9 wild-type proteins (genotypes A–F), respectively, panel 3 included 16 natural HBsAg variants.ResultsLODs ranged from 0.011 to 0.095 IU/ml with the WHO standard, and from 0.021 to 0.326 ng/ml with the French reference. The overall percentage of positive signals using HBsAg variants ranged from 62.9% to 97.9%. Three substitutions: T123, D144A and G145, were negative at all concentrations with at least one assay.DiscussionOur findings show that, although they fulfil CE requirements for analytical sensitivity (LODs below 0.13 IU/ml), HBsAg assays may vary in their capacity to detect HBsAg variants. This limit in diagnosis performance should encourage the health regulatory agencies to include HBsAg variant panels in the evaluation process.