Sensitivity study for CT image use in Monte Carlo treatment planning

An important step in Monte Carlo treatment planning (MCTP), which is commonly performed uncritically, is segmentation of the patient CT data into a voxel phantom for dose calculation. In addition to assigning mass densities to voxels, as is done in conventional TP, this entails assigning media. Mis-assignment of media can potentially lead to significant dose errors in MCTP. In this work, a test phantom with exact-known composition was used to study CT segmentation errors and to quantify subsequent MCTP inaccuracies. For our test cases, we observed dose errors in some regions of up to 10% for 6 and 15 MV photons, more than 30% for an 18 MeV electron beam and more than 40% for 250 kVp photons. It is concluded that a careful CT calibration with a suitable phantom is essential. Generic calibrations and the use of commercial CT phantoms have to be critically assessed.