Efficacy of Modified Lightbulb Technique by Percutaneous Femoral Neck-Head Fenestration Combined With Compacted Artificial Bone Graft for Treating Precollapse Osteonecrosis of the Femoral Head

BackgroundWhether artificial bone provides comparable outcomes to autogenous bone has not been determined for osteonecrosis of the femoral head (ONFH). This study was conducted to compare the clinical outcomes of autogenous and artificial bone grafting (demineralized bone matrix/calcium sulfate DBM/CaS]) through a modified lightbulb technique by percutaneous femoral neck-head fenestration for treating precollapse ONFH.MethodsA total of 73 Association Research Circulation Osseous Stage Ⅱ ONFH patients (81 hips) who had a mean follow-up of 61 months (range, 52 to 74) were included in this retrospective study. Among them were 40 hips treated with autogenous bone and 41 hips treated with DBM/CaS grafting through the percutaneous femoral neck-head fenestration. The Harris scores, radiographic progressions, clinical success rates, and survival analyses were analyzed.ResultsAt final follow-up, the mean Harris score was 80 points (range, 63 to 92) in the DBM/CaS group and 76 points (range, 69 to 91) in the autogenous bone group (P = .751). The radiographic progression rate was 29.9% in the DBM/CaS group, without significant difference from the autogenous bone group, which was 37.5% (P = .43). About 73.2% of patients in the DBM/CaS group and 75% in the autologous bone group avoided a total hip arthroplasty (P = .85). Survival analysis for femoral head protection revealed similar outcomes between the 2 groups (P > .05).ConclusionPercutaneous femoral neck-head fenestration combined with artificial bone (DBM/CaS) grafting had comparable clinical outcomes to autologous bone grafting on preventing femoral head collapse and rescuing THA at a mean of 61-month follow-up for treating early ONFH.