Volatile-consuming reactions fracture rocks and self-accelerate fluid flow in the lithosphere

Hydration and carbonation reactions within the Earth cause an increase in solid volume by up to several tens of vol%, which can induce stress and rock fracture. Observations of naturally hydrated and carbonated peridotite suggest that permeability and fluid flow are enhanced by reaction-induced fracturing. However, permeability enhancement during solid-volume–increasing reactions has not been achieved in the laboratory, and the mechanisms of reaction-accelerated fluid flow remain largely unknown. Here, we present experimental evidence of significant permeability enhancement by volume-increasing reactions under confining pressure. The hydromechanical behavior of hydration of sintered periclase MgO + H₂O → Mg(OH)₂] depends mainly on the initial pore-fluid connectivity. Permeability increased by three orders of magnitude for low-connectivity samples, whereas it decreased by two orders of magnitude for high-connectivity samples. Permeability enhancement was caused by hierarchical fracturing of the reacting materials, whereas a decrease was associated with homogeneous pore clogging by the reaction products. These behaviors suggest that the fluid flow rate, relative to reaction rate, is the main control on hydromechanical evolution during volume-increasing reactions. We suggest that an extremely high reaction rate and low pore-fluid connectivity lead to local stress perturbations and are essential for reaction-induced fracturing and accelerated fluid flow during hydration/carbonation.

Hydration and carbonation reactions in the crust and mantle transport H₂O and CO₂ from Earth’s surface to the interior and control volatile budgets within the Earth (1–6). These reactions are characterized by solid-volume increase, by up to several tens of vol%, which induces stress that may lead to fracturing (7–10). The driving force of such stress generation is the thermodynamic free energy released when metastable anhydrous/noncarbonate minerals react with fluids (7). The stress generated by the reaction has the potential to cause rock fracture and fragmentation (7, 11–13), thereby increasing the reactive surface area and fluid flow and further accelerating the reactions (7, 8, 14). Such chemical breaking of rocks, or reaction-induced fracturing, appears to be important in driving hydration and carbonation reactions to completion (8, 15, 16) in an otherwise self-limiting process where reaction products can clog pores and suppress fluid flow, thereby hindering the reaction (15, 17).Observations of naturally serpentinized and fractured ultramafic rocks indicate a volume increase of 20 to 60% during hydration reactions (13, 18–20), providing evidence of an accelerated supply of fluids during hydration (Fig. 1 A and B). Natural carbonation of ultramafic rocks is also associated with extensive fracture networks, and reaction-induced fracturing is considered a key process in mineral carbonation (Fig. 1C) (7, 8, 21). Numerical simulations indicate a positive feedback between volume-increasing reaction, fracturing, and fluid flow (10, 22–32). Laboratory experiments partially reproduce fracturing during peridotite carbonation, serpentinization, and periclase hydration (29, 33–36); however, hydrothermal flow-through experiments of peridotite serpentinization and carbonation show a decrease in permeability and deceleration of fluid flow and reaction rate (37–42). Observations of the natural carbonation of serpentinized peridotite indicate the decrease in permeability and reduced fluid flow and reaction rate are a consequence of pore clogging related to carbonation (43). Until now, no experimental studies have shown a clear increase in permeability during expansive fluid–rock reactions under confining pressure. As such, despite their geological and environmental importance, the evolution of expansive fluid–rock reactions remains difficult to predict, owing to the complex hydraulic–chemical–mechanical feedbacks underlying these reactions (15, 16, 44). The processes controlling the self-acceleration or deceleration of these reactions remain largely unknown.Open in a separate windowFig. 1.Reaction-induced fractures related to natural hydration/carbonation. (A) Polygonal block of serpentinite cut by planar lizardite veins, extracted from a serpentinite body, San Andreas Lake, California. (B) Photomicrograph of mesh structure in partly serpentinized peridotite, Redwood City serpentinite, California crossed-polarized light (61)]. (C) Quartz veins in silica–carbonate rocks (i.e., listvenite, a carbonated ultramafic rock) that occur along the boundaries of serpentinite bodies, San Jose, California. ol, olivine; serp, serpentine (lizardite ± antigorite mixture); br, brucite.Here, we use the hydration of periclase to brucite MgO + H₂O → Mg(OH)₂] as an analog for solid-volume–increasing reactions in the Earth. This reaction produces an extreme solid-volume increase of 119%, with a high reaction rate at 100 to 600 °C (45). Previous experimental studies on periclase hydration have revealed that extensive fracturing occurs under certain conditions (29, 33, 35), yet the links between fracturing experiments (periclase hydration), nonfracturing experiments (peridotite hydration/carbonation), and natural observations are unknown. On the basis of in situ observations of fluid flow during the reactions, we clearly show that fluid flow and associated permeability are strongly enhanced by solid-volume–increasing reactions under confining pressure (i.e., at simulated depth). Based on the experimental results and nondimensional parameterization, we propose that the ratio of the initial fluid flow rate to the reaction rate has a primary control on the self-acceleration and deceleration of fluid flow and reactions during hydration and carbonation within the Earth.