Distinct roles of the photosystem II protein PsbS and zeaxanthin in the regulation of light harvesting in plants revealed by fluorescence lifetime snapshots

The photosystem II (PSII) protein PsbS and the enzyme violaxanthin deepoxidase (VDE) are known to influence the dynamics of energy-dependent quenching (qE), the component of nonphotochemical quenching (NPQ) that allows plants to respond to fast fluctuations in light intensity. Although the absence of PsbS and VDE has been shown to change the amount of quenching, there have not been any measurements that can detect whether the presence of these proteins alters the type of quenching that occurs. The chlorophyll fluorescence lifetime probes the excited-state chlorophyll relaxation dynamics and can be used to determine the amount of quenching as well as whether two different genotypes with the same amount of NPQ have similar dynamics of excited-state chlorophyll relaxation. We measured the fluorescence lifetimes on whole leaves of Arabidopsis thaliana throughout the induction and relaxation of NPQ for wild type and the qE mutants, npq4, which lacks PsbS; npq1, which lacks VDE and cannot convert violaxanthin to zeaxanthin; and npq1 npq4, which lacks both VDE and PsbS. These measurements show that although PsbS changes the amount of quenching and the rate at which quenching turns on, it does not affect the relaxation dynamics of excited chlorophyll during quenching. In addition, the data suggest that PsbS responds not only to ΔpH but also to the Δψ across the thylakoid membrane. In contrast, the presence of VDE, which is necessary for the accumulation of zeaxanthin, affects the excited-state chlorophyll relaxation dynamics.Plants regulate light harvesting by photosystem II (PSII) in response to changes in light intensity. One way that plants are able to regulate light harvesting is through turning on and off mechanisms that dissipate excess energy. This energy dissipation is assessed via nonphotochemical quenching (NPQ) measurements of chlorophyll fluorescence. Energy-dependent quenching (qE) is the NPQ process with the fastest kinetics. It turns on and off in seconds to minutes, allowing plants to respond to rapid fluctuations in light intensity, which is thought to reduce photodamage (1, 2).Illumination causes the formation of gradients of electrical potential (Δψ) and of proton concentration (ΔpH) across the thylakoid membrane. Although it has been suggested that Δψ may play a role in qE (3), only ΔpH is thought to trigger different proteins and enzymes to induce qE (4). The major known factors involved in induction of qE are the enzyme violaxanthin deepoxidase (VDE) (5) and the PSII protein PsbS (6). The mutant npq1, which lacks VDE and cannot convert violaxanthin to zeaxanthin, has a phenotype with lower qE compared with the wild type (7). Transient absorption measurements suggest that zeaxanthin may quench excited chlorophyll (8). The npq4 mutant, which lacks PsbS, shows no rapidly reversible quenching of chlorophyll fluorescence, suggesting that PsbS is required for qE in vivo (6). PsbS is pH sensitive (9) but is not thought to bind pigments, and thus is likely not the site of quenching (10). It has therefore been hypothesized that PsbS plays an indirect role in quenching, perhaps facilitating a rearrangement of proteins within the grana (11–13). In this paper, we examine the fluorescence lifetime of chlorophyll throughout the induction and relaxation of quenching in intact leaves with and without PsbS and zeaxanthin to examine whether PsbS and zeaxanthin change the type of quenching that occurs in plants.The amount and dynamics of qE are generally measured by changes in the chlorophyll fluorescence yield. One limitation of the chlorophyll fluorescence yield is that it can only inform on the amount of quenching, not on excited-state chlorophyll relaxation dynamics, which reflect how chlorophyll is quenched. Despite this issue, the amount of quenching is commonly used as a proxy for the type of quenching by separating components of quenching based on kinetics, mutants, and the effects of chemical inhibitors. By artificially increasing ΔpH in isolated chloroplasts from npq4, Johnson and Ruban (14, 15) have been able to increase the amount of quenching in npq4 plants to levels observed in wild type plants, suggesting that PsbS may catalyze qE. One potential complication with these studies is that the use of the chemical mediators of cyclic electron transport often necessitates studying isolated chloroplasts rather than intact leaves. In addition, the observation of equivalent amounts of quenching still does not prove that the type of quenching in npq4 is the same as in wild type.In contrast with fluorescence yield measurements, fluorescence lifetime measurements can be used to determine whether the relaxation dynamics of excited chlorophyll are modified by different mutations, informing on the role of a protein or molecule during quenching. The relaxation dynamics of excited chlorophyll during NPQ depends on many variables, including the distance to a quencher, the interactions between the orbitals of chlorophyll and the quencher, and the number of quenchers (16). The shape of the fluorescence lifetime decay curve can be used to determine whether two samples have similar excited chlorophyll relaxation dynamics. Our results show that, although the presence of PsbS does not alter excited chlorophyll relaxation dynamics, the absence of VDE does. These measurements are performed in intact leaves without any chemical treatments, and the data strongly suggest that PsbS plays a catalytic role in vivo.