Comparative evaluation of computerized tomography/magnetic resonance (1.5 T) in the detection of brain metastasis]

Forty-four patients with small cell carcinoma of the bronchus underwent CT and MR studies of the brain to detect cerebral metastases. All patients were studied with contrast-enhanced CT scans, short (T1-weighted) and long (T2-weighted), spin-echo (SE) and FLASH 90 degrees MR sequences. Gd-DTPA enhanced SE-T1 and FLASH 90 degrees sequences were also obtained. A quantitative comparison of the results was carried out to assess the sensitivity of the different techniques in the detection of brain metastases according to lesion diameter. Metastases were identified in 19/44 patients (43%). All techniques detected the lesions greater than 2 cm; of the metastases less than 2 cm, 63/124 (51%) were detected only by Gd-DTPA SE-T1 and FLASH sequences and 11 more (9%) only by Gd-DTPA SE-T1 scans. All the lesions identified on enhanced CT scans or on T2-weighted images were easily detected by Gd-DTPA scans. CT sensitivity was higher than that of pre-contrast SE-T1 and FLASH studies and only slightly lower than that of T2-weighted images. As for lesions less than 2 cm, Gd-DTPA T1-weighted sequences had the highest detection rate (124 lesions) versus Gd-DTPA FLASH 90 degrees scans (113 lesions) and precontrast T1-weighted scans (45 lesions). When comparing Gd-DTPA SE-T1 and FLASH 90 degrees sequences in the detection of lesions less than 1 cm, we observed that the latter missed 9% of metastases, mainly due to a high rate of magnetic susceptibility artifacts and to lower contrast resolution. Therefore, Gd-DTPA SE-T1 images still remain the most accurate technique in the assessment of cerebral metastases.