Stressful events,mastery, and depression: An evaluation of crisis theory

The effect of prior stressful events and mastery on psychological distress during and following a threat to life was examined, and three competing models concerning the effect of prior stressful events on reactions to severe life crisis were compared. The stressful events model suggests that prior stressful events increase vulnerability to new threatening events. The traditional crisis model suggests no such effect of prior stressful events on crisis reaction due to the overwhelming effect of the crisis at hand. A facilitator model predicts that prior events decrease vulnerability to crisis due to a “practice effect.” Fifty-five Israeli women (not found to have cancer) were studied just prior to and 3 months following biopsy for suspected cancer. Those with greater prior stressful events were significantly more state depressed at both times than those experiencing fewer events, supporting the stressful events model. It was also found that mastery moderated the extent to which women were depressed and the period of time they remained depressed. However, mastery did not limit the stressful life event — depression relationship. Implications for research and intervention are discussed.